Podcast Episodes

The Alien Abduction of Betty & Barney Hill [Ep. 132]

Season 1 Episode 141

In the 1960s, a married couple from New Hampshire would share their unbelievable close encounter with the third kind. Their story would make headline…

1 year, 3 months ago

View Episode

A Perplexing Listenersode: Vol. 2 [Ep. 131]

Season 1 Episode 140

Kaydra dives into another volume of perplexing listener stories! Enjoy 5 stories from listeners like you. Have a story you'd like to submit? Email Ka…

1 year, 4 months ago

View Episode

The Wendorf Murders & Kentucky Teen Vampire Cult ft Like Mother Like Murder [Ep. 130]

Season 1 Episode 139

Kaydra takes a break from story tellng this week and brings you a special feed drop: a crossover episode she recorded several months ago with Like Mo…

1 year, 4 months ago

View Episode

The Aswang & The Manananggal [Ep. 129]

Season 1 Episode 138

Today we will be discussing the most feared monster in all of Filipino folklore. These shapeshifting creatures appear as humans during the day, and t…

1 year, 4 months ago

View Episode

The Tetris Murders ft Astonishing Legends [Ep. 128]

Season 1 Episode 137

Vladimir Pokhilko was the president of AnimaTek, a software company based out of San Francisco, CA. The conclusion of his legacy for the last 2 decad…

1 year, 4 months ago

View Episode

The Blount Family Bombing [Ep. 127]

Season 1 Episode 136

On Thanksgiving evening, November 28, 1985, there would be a deadly explosion at Hilltop Mobile Home Park at 7800 Jacksboro Highway between Lake Wort…

1 year, 5 months ago

View Episode

Fort Concho & Haunted San Angelo [Ep. 126]

Season 1 Episode 135

Established in 1867, Fort Concho was built along the banks of the Concho River in San Angelo, Texas to protect frontier settlements, patrol and map t…

1 year, 5 months ago

View Episode

Creepy r/LetsNotMeet Stories [Ep. 125]

Season 1 Episode 134

In this Patreon leak episode, Kaydra shares 3 spine tingling encounters from the /LetsNotMeet subreddit. These are terrifying allegedly true stories …

1 year, 5 months ago

View Episode

The Disappearances of Brian Shaffer & Niqui McCown ft A Trial By Podcast [Ep. 124]

Season 1 Episode 133

In another special collaborative episode, Perplexity brings you a double disappearance episode. Kelsey from A Trial by Podcast tells the infamous sto…

1 year, 5 months ago

View Episode

Mysterious Deaths: Phoebe Handsjuk & Jelani Day ft Serial Napper [Ep. 123]

Season 1 Episode 132

In this special collaborative episode, Kaydra brings on Nikki from the Serial Napper podcast. The ladies share 2 mysterious and suspicious death case…

1 year, 6 months ago

View Episode