Podcast Episodes
Back to SearchMy Dog Ate My Roommate
Season 1 Episode 264
This week, Karl and Vinnie present their picks for the Creepiest Roommate, Karl brings another wild Cop Cam clip featuring a very eager citizen on a ride along, and we investigate whether the Messiah…
Published on 6 months, 3 weeks ago
2025 Memorial Day Scum Parade
Season 1 Episode 263
With Karl away, Vinnie is joined by the Golden Voice of Syracuse, Bryan McBride, and show newcomer Kevin Reynolds for a brand-new Scum Parade and two wild Cop Cam videos—one featuring a pizza freakou…
Published on 7 months ago
Piss for Pat's
Season 1 Episode 262
The Creep-Off is back! Karl & Vinnie return with a brand-new category: Creepiest Rideshare Driver. Buckle up as they each nominate a true nightmare behind the wheel—predators, psychos, and five-star …
Published on 7 months, 1 week ago
Live From Las Vegas 2
Season 1 Episode 261
Karl & Vinnie are live from the Plaza Hotel for an all-out showdown to name the biggest creep in Sin City. It’s the Hackamania Battle you’ve been waiting for — featuring the “Vegas Scum Parade All-S…
Published on 7 months, 2 weeks ago
I'll Show You Sloppy Work!
Season 1 Episode 260
Karl and Vinnie are back — and this time they’ve brought in their pal, the Voice of Syracuse, Brian McBride! It’s a triple-threat creep showdown as they hunt for the title of creepiest electrician. T…
Published on 8 months ago
Island Boys
Season 1 Episode 259
In this episode Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head in another wildcard round of the show! This is an anything-goes episode, there are no categories—just creeps. Any creep who hasn’t been covered before …
Published on 8 months, 1 week ago
Sugarfoot vs Snaggle Foot
Season 1 Episode 258
Welcome back, creepos! Karl and Vinnie are no strangers to the Sunshine State. This week, in honor of their trip to "Dabble House," they’ll be making their nominations for the biggest creep in the st…
Published on 8 months, 3 weeks ago
The Lust Boat
Season 1 Episode 257
Grab your shopping carts, creeps—this week on The Creep-Off, Vinnie and Karl stroll down the aisles to nominate the Biggest Creep in the Supermarket! We’ll also break down wild police footage in our …
Published on 8 months, 4 weeks ago
O' Carly
Season 1 Episode 256
Get ready to tip off March Madness the Creep-Off way! Vinnie and Karl dive into the darkest corners of college hoops history to crown the Creepiest College Basketball Player of All Time! Don’t forget…
Published on 9 months ago
Do You Smell Fried Chicken?
Season 1 Episode 255
Get ready for a twisted St. Patrick’s Day special from The Creep-Off! This week, Vinnie and Karl each nominate their pick for the most disturbing creeps ever linked to everyone's favorite day of drin…
Published on 9 months, 1 week ago