Podcast Episodes

Island Boys

Season 1 Episode 259

In this episode Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head in another wildcard round of the show! This is an anything-goes episode, there are no categories—just…

11 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

Sugarfoot vs Snaggle Foot

Season 1 Episode 258

Welcome back, creepos! Karl and Vinnie are no strangers to the Sunshine State. This week, in honor of their trip to "Dabble House," they’ll be making…

1 year ago

View Episode

The Lust Boat

Season 1 Episode 257

Grab your shopping carts, creeps—this week on The Creep-Off, Vinnie and Karl stroll down the aisles to nominate the Biggest Creep in the Supermarket!…

1 year ago

View Episode

O' Carly

Season 1 Episode 256

Get ready to tip off March Madness the Creep-Off way! Vinnie and Karl dive into the darkest corners of college hoops history to crown the Creepiest C…

1 year ago

View Episode

Do You Smell Fried Chicken?

Season 1 Episode 255

Get ready for a twisted St. Patrick’s Day special from The Creep-Off! This week, Vinnie and Karl each nominate their pick for the most disturbing cre…

1 year, 1 month ago

View Episode

Welcome to the USA!

Season 1 Episode 254

Welcome back, creepos! This week on The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie saddle up and head to San Antonio, Texas and make their nominations for biggest cr…

1 year, 1 month ago

View Episode

You Down With O.D.D?

Season 1 Episode 252

Today, Karl is on vacation, and Vinnie has accepted a challenge from Once Over with Cayley's Lucy Tightbox! Today's category: creeps who inspired mov…

1 year, 1 month ago

View Episode

You Better Put Down a Towel…

Season 1 Episode 251

This week, we’re nominating the creepiest airline employee of all time (shocker—there are a lot to choose from). Don’t forget to vote for the one who…

1 year, 1 month ago

View Episode

I Can Fix Her

Season 1 Episode 250

In this episode of "The Creep Off," Karl is joined by Eric Zane for a discussion about some of the latest bizarre news stories in their scum parade s…

1 year, 2 months ago

View Episode

Cobra!

Season 1 Episode 249

This week, we’re diving into the darkest crimes from New Orleans to crown the Biggest Creep in The Big Easy. Don’t forget to vote for who brought the…

1 year, 2 months ago

View Episode