Podcast Episodes

Creepsgiving 2025: A Butthorn 'O Plenty

Season 1 Episode 289

’Tis the start of the holiday season, and Karl & Vinnie are kicking things off the only way they know how — by making their nominations for the bigge…

4 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

Victim Blaming: A Masterclass

Season 1 Episode 288

This week on The Creep Off, we’re headed to the Pacific Northwest for a brutal matchup: Who is the Biggest Creep in Portland? Vinnie and Karl each br…

5 months ago

View Episode

The Most High

Season 1 Episode 287

This week on The Creep Off, Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head with their picks for Creepiest Kid. The score is currently Vinnie 2 - Karl 3 – Guest 4 vi…

5 months ago

View Episode

2:40pm at the Cleaning Factory

Season 1 Episode 286

Today in honor of National Homemaker Day, Karl and Vinnie roll up their sleeves and dive into the world of domestic true crime drama to uncover the c…

5 months, 2 weeks ago

View Episode

Losing my Digestion

Season 1 Episode 285

It’s the most wonderful time of the year — for creeps! Vinnie and Karl dig through the dark history of All Hallows’ Eve to crown the biggest Hallowee…

5 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

A Fat Fish Called Wanda

Season 1 Episode 284

Buckle up for a wild ride on this episode of the creep off! Karl & Vinnie are hitting the open road to crown the Creepiest Trucker of all time, and y…

5 months, 4 weeks ago

View Episode

Dead Asleep

Season 1 Episode 283

It’s the Wild Card Round on The Creep Off. Karl will spin the Wheel of Consequences! Plus, we’ve got a fresh Scum Parade and a new edition of Karl’s …

6 months ago

View Episode

Four is a Crowd

Season 1 Episode 282

This week The Creep Off heads north to the land of 10,000 lakes to find out who truly deserves the crown as Minnesota’s Biggest Creep. Vinnie and Kar…

6 months, 1 week ago

View Episode

The Boy who cried Greenland

Season 1 Episode 281

From locker rooms to lock-ups, college football has had its fair share of shady characters. In this week’s episode, Karl and Vinnie dig through the h…

6 months, 2 weeks ago

View Episode

The Misadventures of Mary Busey

Season 1 Episode 280

Class is in session, creeps! This week Karl & Vinnie dig through the bottom of the substitute bin to find out which fill-in “educator” deserves the t…

6 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode