Podcast Episodes

Ep. 54 - Halloween

Season 2 Episode 54

Happy Halloween from The Supernaturals Podcast! This year we wanted to make it very special. Not only does this episode conclude a very mystical and …

8 months ago

View Episode

Ep. 53 - The Smiley Face Mystery

Season 2 Episode 53

In this chilling episode of The Supernaturals, Jake and Cal discuss the Smiley Face Mystery, a theory that connects the drownings of college-aged men…

8 months, 1 week ago

View Episode

Ep. 52 - The Black Phone 2 & The Case of Jaycee Dugard

Season 2 Episode 52

In this week’s episode, The Supernaturals discuss ‘The Black Phone,’ a movie directed by Scott Derrickson (Sinister) and starring Ethan Hawke. Jake a…

8 months, 2 weeks ago

View Episode

Ep. 51 - Legend of the Wendigo

Season 2 Episode 51

In this episode, The Supernaturals discuss a native Algonquin legend. The people believed in a terrifying creature known as the Wendigo, a haunting c…

8 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

Ep. 50 - Salem Witch Trials (On-Location)

Season 2 Episode 50

In their 50th episode special, The Supernaturals pack up their bags and head to Salem, Massachusetts, where they examine a dark period in American hi…

9 months ago

View Episode

Ep. 49 - Yuba County Five

Season 2 Episode 49

In this unsolved mysteries episode, The Supernaturals discuss what has been dubbed as ‘America’s Dyatlov Pass Incident.’ The story follows five young…

9 months, 1 week ago

View Episode

Ep. 48 - Fan Submissions: Strange Encounters

Season 2 Episode 48

In this special episode, The Supernaturals asked you to send them your terrifying encounters. From stalkings to close calls, Jake and Cal read your s…

9 months, 2 weeks ago

View Episode

Ep. 47 - The Mothman

Season 2 Episode 47

Stemming from West Virginia folklore, there was a creature that was first sighted in 1966 in Point Pleasant. Its massive size, giant wings, and glowi…

9 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

Ep. 46 - Into the Valley of the Headless Men

Season 2 Episode 46

In this intriguing unsolved mysteries episode, The Supernaturals discuss the weird events that occurred at a National Park in Canada. Full of untouch…

10 months ago

View Episode

Ep. 45 - Peoples Temple: The Horrors at Jonestown

Season 2 Episode 45

Part two: In the conclusion of ‘Cult Month,’ The Supernaturals examine the rise and fall of Peoples Temple. While the media began to criticize his ab…

10 months, 1 week ago

View Episode