Podcast Episodes

Ep:12 - A Conversation with Jodie Laird (Reesa Trexler's sister)

Season 1 Episode 12

What happens when police, the community, and even your own family suspect you of cold-blooded killer? The incredible, amazing, inspiring Jodie Laird …

1 year, 8 months ago

View Episode

Ep:11 - The Murder of Reesa Trexler

Season 1 Episode 11

When 15-year-old Reesa Trexler is murdered while visiting her grandparents' house, everyone in Salisbury, NC wonders who's to blame...except for poli…

1 year, 8 months ago

View Episode

Ep:10 - The Gallaudet University Murders

Season 1 Episode 10

Two murders at a world-renowned university for the deaf maKe one man's life a living hell, as the real killer continued his murderous rampage on camp…

1 year, 8 months ago

View Episode

Ep:9 - The Murder of Elizabeth Olten

Season 1 Episode 9

MU wraps up their block on hedonistic killers by diving into the documented psychosis of Cosmo DiNardo before analyzing the horrific actions of Alyss…

1 year, 8 months ago

View Episode

Ep:8 - A Conversation with Phil Claroni (Producer)

Season 1 Episode 8

Friend and fellow true crime producer, Phil Claroni, joins MU for a conversation about the challenges of turning a local horror story into a gripping…

1 year, 9 months ago

View Episode

Ep:7 - The Lost Boys of Bucks County, Pt. 2

Season 1 Episode 7

In the conclusion of MU’s look at the Lost Boys of Bucks County, a hedonistic killer reveals his twisted motives as four Pennsylvania families get th…

1 year, 9 months ago

View Episode

Ep:6 - The Lost Boys of Bucks County, Pt. 1

Season 1 Episode 6

When four boys mysteriously vanish from rural Pennsylvania, the innocence of a peaceful community is permanently shattered. In part 1 of this two-par…

1 year, 9 months ago

View Episode

Ep:5 - The Murder of Stanley Edwards

Season 1 Episode 5

In an emotionally-charged kickoff to MU's second story block, the heartbreaking murder of a young Connecticut boy leaves Ed and Melissa shook as they…

1 year, 9 months ago

View Episode

Ep:4 - The Murder of Robin Benedict

Season 1 Episode 4

Ed and Melissa wrap up their block on bodiless crimes by shedding light on a forgotten victim, whose occupation made her murder back page news.

1 year, 10 months ago

View Episode

Ep:3 - A Conversation with (ret.) NYPD Det. Steve Pelan

Season 1 Episode 3

Ed, Melissa, and guest host, Katie, are joined by retired NYPD Detective Steve Pelan for an intimate conversation about his life, his career, and the…

1 year, 10 months ago

View Episode