Podcast Episodes

Nikki VanderHeyden | 23

Episode 23

Nikki and Doug were ecstatic to get a night out with friends but as they say “nothing good happens past midnight” and they ain’t wrong. Things take a…

3 years, 11 months ago

View Episode

Ellen Halbert | 22

Episode 22

When Ellen Halbert's husband left to play golf & her son went off to school, she had a nice morning in a quiet house. This dream turned into a nightm…

3 years, 11 months ago

View Episode

Pam Butler & Marta Rodriguez | 21

Episode 21

When a D.C. woman mysteriously disappears in 2009, the investigation takes an unexpected turn that sends police down a 30-year rabbit hole. How is Pa…

4 years ago

View Episode

Brittani Marcell | 20

Episode 20

Rachel tells the story of a true badass, Brittani Marcell. This case makes you realize how crazy the human mind is (in a good way) with an unlikely o…

4 years ago

View Episode

John Broyhill and Jamie & Nation Hahn | 19

Episode 19

"We lock our doors at night to keep out evil...but what if evil has a key? You can't prepare for that." Rebecca tells you about the shocking story of…

4 years ago

View Episode

Teresita Basa | 18

Episode 18

Rachel tells the story of Teresita Basa, the only case we know of where the murder victim solves their own crime. How she does it is truly spooky, so…

4 years ago

View Episode

Jessica Dishon | 17

Episode 17

Jessica Dishon's mom came home to see her daughter never went to school. She sees her car in the driveway and her cell phone on the floor board with …

4 years, 1 month ago

View Episode

Cindy James | 16

Episode 16

Scary ass phone calls, threatening notes and physical attacks - for 7 years, Cindy James tried to figure out who was stalking her and why. Police spe…

4 years, 1 month ago

View Episode

Ken and Barbie Killers | 15

Episode 15

Season 2 opener Rebecca tells the story of a very heartless couple and the most shocking twist is that the universe allowed them to meet. SORRY CANAD…

4 years, 1 month ago

View Episode

Nicholas Barclay | 14

Episode 14

In the season 1 finale, Rachel covers the bizarre & tragic story of Nicholas Barclay, a 13 year old who went missing in 1994. Just when his family lo…

4 years, 2 months ago

View Episode