Podcast Episodes

The Unsolved Murder of Judy Rawlings ft A Million Other Choices [Ep. 159]

Season 1 Episode 170

TW/CW: sexual assault and murder of a child

A brutal and unsolved murder of a 16 year old girl left residents of a small town in North Carolina compl…

9 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

A Perplexing Christmas Marathon! Krampus, Creepypasta, UFOs, and Serial Killers [Ep. 158]

Season 1 Episode 169

Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays, everyone! While Kaydra is traveling and enjoying time with her loved ones, enjoy this EARLY rewind... a perplexin…

10 months ago

View Episode

Worst Ex Ever: Benjamin Obadiah Foster [Ep. 157]

Season 1 Episode 168

TW: domestic violence, murder

While Kaydra is working hard behind the scenes this week getting things ready for season 4, she brings to you a remaste…

10 months ago

View Episode

Zombies: History, Folklore, & REAL Cases [Ep. 156]

Season 1 Episode 167

When you think of classic horror creatures… what comes to mind? Vampires? Werewolves? Demons? Absolutely. But what about the undead? Reanimated human…

10 months, 1 week ago

View Episode

Haunted Mississippi: L.Q. Ivy, Haunted Locations & More [Ep. 155]

Season 1 Episode 166

TW: murder, suicide, extreme racial violence

Mississippi’s history whispers through shadows and time. From pre-war mansions where footsteps still ech…

10 months, 2 weeks ago

View Episode

Vanished On Thanksgiving: John Woodruff & Karen Mitchell [Ep. 154]

Season 1 Episode 165

TW: Murder, sexual assault

This time of year is often spent with the ones we love. It’s a time for conversation, connection, laughter, and the comfor…

10 months, 3 weeks ago

View Episode

INTRODUCING: Missing in Hush Town

Season 1 Episode 164

In March 2001, 11-year-old Bethany Leanne Markowski vanished without a trace during a scheduled visit with her father. He claims she walked into the …

10 months, 4 weeks ago

View Episode

Survivor Mary Vincent & Murder of Roxanne Hayes- Larry Singleton [Ep. 153]

Season 1 Episode 163

TW: sexual assault, murder, extreme violence

In September of 1978, 15 year old Mary Vincent was hitchhiking in California. She would accept a ride fr…

11 months ago

View Episode

S3: Perplexity THEME SONG

Season 3

Special thanks to Patrick Thompson for creating this masterpiece! What do you guys think?! Feel free to download and enjoy.

11 months, 1 week ago

View Episode

Lilith the Vampiress [Ep. 152]

Season 1 Episode 162

In some versions of the story of the Garden of Eden, there is a third person: a mysterious vampiress. The story of this Dark Queen can be traced all …

11 months, 1 week ago

View Episode