Podcast Episodes

The Reincarnation of Sandra Jean Jenkins

Season 1 Episode 24

Georgia Rudolph was just 5 years old when she started dreaming about the life of another girl. Then dreams became waking visions that led her to an Ohio river town she never knew existed, but one who…

Published on 6 years, 10 months ago

Bank Heist

Season 1 Episode 23

Episode Notes:

Bank Heist: The Ted Conrad story

Ted Conrad was obsessed with the movie, The Thomas Crown Affair, when it was released in 1968. It inspired the 20-year-old bank teller to pull off hi…

Published on 6 years, 10 months ago

Little Boy Blue

Season 1 Episode 22

The Nebraska town named him Matthew - "gift from God" - when they found his frozen body in a snow-filled ditch. But as authorities spent the next two years trying to find the identity of the little d…

Published on 6 years, 10 months ago

Vanished

Season 1 Episode 21

Episode Notes

The 1963 disappearance of Ruth Guthrie, Tommy Sumerix and Joe Kulesza

Over a period of 10 days in June of 1963, three Summit County children disappeared. For months, three communities …

Published on 6 years, 10 months ago

The disappearance of Mel Wiley

Season 1 Episode 20

Episode 20: The disappearance of Mel Wiley

In 1985, Mel Wiley, the police chief in Medina County's Hinckley Township, tells his girlfriend he's meeting an old friend for a dip in Lake Erie. Three days…

Published on 6 years, 11 months ago

The Hicks Babies

Season 1 Episode 19

Imagine reading a Mother's Day story in your local newspaper, and finding clues that suggest you may have been sold as a baby out the back door of a small clinic in the Appalachian Mountains of Georg…

Published on 6 years, 11 months ago

The First Christmas Tree

Season 1 Episode 18

Episode Notes:

For more than 50 years, the country accepted without question that Wooster, Ohio immigrant August Imgard was the first to decorate a Christmas tree in America. His charming story was to…

Published on 6 years, 11 months ago

Who Poisoned Clifford Badger?

Season 1 Episode 17

On March 15, 1971, sheep rancher Clifford Badger is returning from a morning business trip when he stops to pick up the mail outside his farmhouse in West Salem. He finds a box of homemade chocolates…

Published on 6 years, 11 months ago

The Toledo Clubber

Season 1 Episode 16

In 1925-26, a man with a face painted red and a maniacal laugh stalked the west end of Toledo, randomly selecting women and clubbing them - many, to the death.

A serial killer still unidentified to …

Published on 7 years ago

Missing Melvin Horst

Season 1 Episode 15

Two days after Christmas in 1928, 4-year-old Melvin Horst is playing in a vacant lot with a friend when he realizes its dinner time. "Goodbye, Bobbie. I got to go home now," he says. An hour later, a…

Published on 7 years ago