Podcast Episodes
Back to Search
To Catch A Cheater - Winter & Kent - Private Texts, Public Betrayal
Winter had a gut feeling something was off — the distance, the late-night texting, and an awkward moment she can’t unsee. When her boyfriend Kent sta…
11 months ago
Caleb & Naomi - Ghosted After the Hot Sauce Challenge?
Caleb thought his pottery date with Naomi was going great — until the infamous hot sauce challenge went sideways, and now he’s getting ghosted. What …
11 months ago
To Catch A Cheater - Bill & Kathy - Insomnia or Infidelity?
When Bill's wife starts sneaking out in the middle of the night, he fears the worst—especially with unexplained charges showing up on their bank acco…
11 months ago
Celly Cell Strikes Again: Corn, Chemistry & a Public Chase?
Repeat guest Celly Cell is back on the scene with another unforgettable first date follow-up—and things escalated fast. From flirty food festival vib…
11 months ago
Maelan & Trevor - Haunted or Hot? The Ice Cream Date That Got Ghosted
Maelan swears her first date with Trevor was unforgettable — karaoke, a romantic ice cream moment, and an unexpected kiss that left her mind spinning…
11 months, 1 week ago
To Catch A Cheater - Ashley & Ryan - When the Assistant Has a Husband Too…
Ashley thought her boyfriend of four years was just busy with work — until the late nights, cold shoulder, and constant messages raised some serious …
11 months, 1 week ago
The Silent Treatment... or the Silent Toot?
When Natasha hooked up with Mason after a fiery first date, she thought things were off to an amazing start. But now he’s ghosting her—despite workin…
11 months, 1 week ago
Tori & Mason - Too Much Too Soon? The Taco Date That Turned Poetic
When tacos, poetry, and a parking garage kiss set the stage for romance, what could possibly go wrong? In this emotionally charged episode of First D…
11 months, 1 week ago
To Catch A Cheater - Candace & Jesse - A Second Apartment and a Secret Flower Delivery
Candace thought her relationship was solid—until she found out her boyfriend Jesse never gave up his old apartment. After two years together and six …
11 months, 1 week ago
Damon & Hazel - The Sound of Chewing... and Ghosting?
Damon thought he had a picture-perfect first date—flirty vibes, pizza, and even a goodnight kiss. But when Hazel completely ghosts him, he turns to J…
11 months, 1 week ago