Podcast Episodes
Back to Search
To Catch A Cheater - Bill & Kathy - Insomnia or Infidelity?
When Bill's wife starts sneaking out in the middle of the night, he fears the worst—especially with unexplained charges showing up on their bank acco…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
Celly Cell Strikes Again: Corn, Chemistry & a Public Chase?
Repeat guest Celly Cell is back on the scene with another unforgettable first date follow-up—and things escalated fast. From flirty food festival vib…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
Maelan & Trevor - Haunted or Hot? The Ice Cream Date That Got Ghosted
Maelan swears her first date with Trevor was unforgettable — karaoke, a romantic ice cream moment, and an unexpected kiss that left her mind spinning…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
To Catch A Cheater - Ashley & Ryan - When the Assistant Has a Husband Too…
Ashley thought her boyfriend of four years was just busy with work — until the late nights, cold shoulder, and constant messages raised some serious …
7 months, 2 weeks ago
The Silent Treatment... or the Silent Toot?
When Natasha hooked up with Mason after a fiery first date, she thought things were off to an amazing start. But now he’s ghosting her—despite workin…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
Tori & Mason - Too Much Too Soon? The Taco Date That Turned Poetic
When tacos, poetry, and a parking garage kiss set the stage for romance, what could possibly go wrong? In this emotionally charged episode of First D…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
To Catch A Cheater - Candace & Jesse - A Second Apartment and a Secret Flower Delivery
Candace thought her relationship was solid—until she found out her boyfriend Jesse never gave up his old apartment. After two years together and six …
7 months, 2 weeks ago
Damon & Hazel - The Sound of Chewing... and Ghosting?
Damon thought he had a picture-perfect first date—flirty vibes, pizza, and even a goodnight kiss. But when Hazel completely ghosts him, he turns to J…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
Ruby & Jordan - Ghosted After One Kiss?
After a dreamy aviation museum date, Ruby thought she'd found her wingman for life—until Jordan completely vanished. From jet-fueled flirtation to un…
7 months, 2 weeks ago
To Catch A Cheater - Katie & Seth - The Flowers, the Friend, and the Fitness Routine
Katie thought her husband Seth might be cheating—after all, he suddenly started working out every day, eating healthier, and spending a lot more time…
7 months, 2 weeks ago