Podcast Episodes
Back to Search
BREAKING: Adnan Syed Released From Prison (Our Reaction and What's Next?)
Episode 115
BREAKING NEWS: A judge has vacated Adnan Syed's original murder conviction from 1999 in a hearing today. Adnan Syed was released from prison, walked …
4 years, 1 month ago
#86 - Locked And Left For Dead
Episode 114
When a 17 year old girl misses school for an entire month, social workers show up to her home only for her mother, Banita Jacks, to deny them any inf…
4 years, 1 month ago
NMR #27 - John Invades Daryn's Apartment
Episode 113
John and Daryn finally talk about the elephant in the room: John staying at Daryn's apartment like he's Kevin McCallister from Home Alone. And he has…
4 years, 1 month ago
#85 - I Dreamed of Murder (Flashback)
Episode 112
Due to unexpected circumstances John was unable to record a new show this week. However, this flashback episode will be worth the listen!
Was a man's …
4 years, 2 months ago
#84 - Rattlesnake James
Episode 111
In the early 1900s a man tried to capitalize on a life insurance policy by murdering his wife with rattlesnakes. It's as disturbing as you might thin…
4 years, 2 months ago
#83 - Murdered For Silver (Flashback)
Episode 110
We're taking a week of from recording a new episode while we both are getting our last bit of summer vacays in! This episode was a fun one because we…
4 years, 2 months ago
#82 - Haunted To Death
Episode 109
The phone flew across the room on its own. The lights were turning on without anyone touching the switch. This house was right out of The Poltergeist…
4 years, 2 months ago
#81 - Her Children Keep Dying
Episode 108
One after another, Marybeth Tinning's infant children would show up in a hospital with no clear health issues, only to die within minutes. It isn't u…
4 years, 2 months ago
NMR #26 - Daddy Cat, Come On Down!
Episode 107
John wants Daryn to join him in the studio audience for The Price is Right one day. They discuss their strategies for how to get on stage. RIP Olivia…
4 years, 2 months ago
#80 - The Devil's Pitchfork
Episode 106
A man in the United Kingdom gets put away for some of the most heinous crimes imaginable, and somehow gets released. What happens next will boil your…
4 years, 3 months ago