Podcast Episodes
Back to Search
Weird Herb: The I-70 Strangler
Season 1 Episode 32
At a time when gay men were disappearing from Indianapolis bars, Herb Baumeister was running a successful business and purchasing a beautiful farm. B…
5 years, 5 months ago
Susie Jaeger
Season 1 Episode 31
When the Jaegers' took a month long trip from Michigan out West, they knew that it would be a trip that they would never forget. Their trip ended in …
5 years, 5 months ago
Texarkana's Phantom Slayer
Season 1 Episode 30
As kids, we heard the scary story about a couple parked on lover’s lane that narrowly misses their demise. The case of Texarkana’s Phantom Slayer is …
5 years, 5 months ago
Jessica Keen
Season 1 Episode 29
The murder of Jessica Keen rocked the Columbus, OH community in 1991. It was not only the brutality of her murder that stunned investigators, but it …
5 years, 5 months ago
Mary Ann Cotton
Season 1 Episode 28
Before Jack the Ripper, there was Mary Ann Cotton. One could describe her as "The Mother of all Serial Killers". Meg takes you through the absolutely…
5 years, 6 months ago
The Kičevo Monster
Season 1 Episode 27
From 2004-2008 the city of Kičevo was terrorized by their first serial killer. Dubbed The Kičevo Monster, terror spread through the small mountain to…
5 years, 6 months ago
The Playboy Bunny Curse
Season 1 Episode 26
Playboy is an iconic brand but are the women that work for them doomed? Meg takes you through some of the most horrific cases that affected Playboy b…
5 years, 6 months ago
The Murder of Arlis Perry
Season 1 Episode 25
Arlis Perry was brutally murdered in the church on Stanford Campus in Palo Alto California in October 1974. In a time of "Satanic Panic", coming off …
5 years, 6 months ago
The Murder of Holly Bobo
Season 1 Episode 24
It's a listener request this week! Holly Bobo was a beautiful 20 year old who had her entire life ahead of her when she was approached by a man in he…
5 years, 7 months ago
Andy Castillo
Season 1 Episode 23
Andy Castillo was arrested in January 2020 on charges of cyber stalking realtors. When over 100 realtors reported that they had been receiving harass…
5 years, 7 months ago