Podcast Episodes
Back to SearchCreepmas 3: Leather Kilts and Mistletoe
Season 1 Episode 144
In this very special Creepmas edition of the show we celebrate Karl's birthday with the biggest holiday themed creeps we could find, and we finally accept your listener challenges: In the scum-parade…
Published on 3 years ago
He Sees You When You’re Sleeping
Season 1 Episode 143
This week Karl and Vinnie determine who is the creepiest Mall Santa of all time: In WATC we finally learn "Why We Drink": In the Scum Parade we meet a bad friend, and we learn that Florida is not a g…
Published on 3 years ago
Audiophile
Season 1 Episode 142
In honor of the World Cup, Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest footballer: In WATC we meet the ladies from New Zealand based true crime podcast “sinister Dynasty”: In the scum parade…
Published on 3 years ago
Stupid Masterminds
Season 1 Episode 141
This week we follow Creeps-giving with our very first "Black Friday" themed episode: In WATC Karl discovered a brand-new true crime podcast that claims to be about the victims, not the criminals. Did…
Published on 3 years, 1 month ago
Creepsgiving III: Kevin and His Weezer Band
Season 1 Episode 140
Karl and Vinnie celebrate another Creepsgiving with the worst creep's Thanksgiving has to offer: In WATC we prove that we are better than "True Crime Garage: This week's scum parade features a man wh…
Published on 3 years, 1 month ago
The Wildest of Cards
Season 1 Episode 139
In this episode Vinnie spins the wheel of consequences, and we kick off the new round with a no holds barred wildcard match: In WATC we prove that we are better than "Crime Junkie": In the Scum Parad…
Published on 3 years, 1 month ago
Zumock vs. Bundy (This Ain't No Meet Cute)
Season 1 Episode 138
This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest "Chad" inadvertently creating the most important vote in Creep Off History: Our Podcast Hitman song parody contest begins, and we prove …
Published on 3 years, 1 month ago
Hey Kid, Get In the Casket!
Season 1 Episode 137
This week we give last year’s Halloween episode the sequel it deserves: In WATC Karl proves that the “the Vanished” podcast sucks: In the Scum Parade Alabama man is at it again, we learn why you shou…
Published on 3 years, 1 month ago
Tie a String Around Your Finger
Season 1 Episode 136
This week Karl and Vinnie make their nominations for biggest creep from the Garden State of New Jersey: Karl read the letter we received from the currently jailed Podcast Hitman: in the Scum Parade w…
Published on 3 years, 2 months ago
Uncle Saul
Season 1 Episode 135
This week Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for the creepiest information technology specialist: in this weeks “Who are these Creeps” we pay tribute to the second greatest true crime podcaster in …
Published on 3 years, 2 months ago