Episode Details
Back to EpisodesWhen talking with a transgender person, which pronoun should you use?
Published 6 years, 11 months ago
Description
Pastor J.D. discusses transgenderism, gender ambiguity, and the concept of pronoun hospitality.
A glimpse inside this episode:
Old maxim: Behind every question is a questioner.
- When I hear a question like this, I immediately imagine the sort of person asking it. Sometimes it may be someone trying to pick a fight.
- But behind those who identify as transgender, that experience is invariably a person filled with confusion, pain, and rejection.
- Sadly, the church has often failed to be the sanctuary of the hurting for people in the LGBTQ community. We need to acknowledge that and repent of it.
- Behind every case of ssa or gender dysphoria is a question about unanswered prayer.
Before we talk about trans pronouns, I think it may be helpful to talk a little bit about transgenderism more broadly.
-
- Two excellent books (that far excel my own knowledge here):
- Ryan Anderson, When Harry Became Sally: Responding to the Transgender Moment
-
-
-
- He deals with these questions (about sex vs. gender, pronoun usage, etc) in a very straightforward while (usually) grace-filled way.
- Andrew Walker, God and the Transgender Debate.
-
-
- 1. What determines your gender? Anatomy? Identity?
-
-
- The real answer is genetics: However things look on the outside, sex (male/female) is hardwired into our DNA. But since the external manifestations of sex do not always cohere with the genetics, scientists use the helpful phrase, “genetic sex.” This refers to whether a person has XY or XX chromosomes. Genetic sex is established at conception, and is a binary. Despite advances in medical technology, there is still no way of altering this, as it is a part of our DNA. No matter what sexual reassignment surgeries people undergo, or what hormonal supplements they take, they will always have the genetic sex they did at conception.
- There are periodic mutations in which individuals get other unconventional combinations (besides XX or XY), the most common of which is XXY. (This is called Klinefelter syndrome.) But even though this is the most common genetic sex disorder, it only occurs in about 1 in 1,000 men—and most of them never manifest symptoms. If they do manifest symptoms, it is usually via infertility.
- All told, when it comes to genetic sex, at the DNA level, there really is just male and female.
-
- QUESTION 2. What about ambiguous Genitalia and the “Intersexual”
-
- Now, when it comes to external anatomy, the situation is slightly different. Sometimes a genetically female child will have an enlarged clitoris (resembling a penis), or a genetically male child will lack one (or both) testicles. In most of these cases, the abnormality is minor and can be corrected surgically. This is sometimes referred to as “ambiguous genitalia,” though some people with this condition prefer the title “intersexual.”
- Again, the numbers here are very small. Only 1 in 1,000 babies undergoes corrective surgery for genitalia abnormalities. Not all cases of ambiguous genitalia require corrective surgery, of course, so the number of instances may be higher—though only slightly so.
- But here’