Episode Details

Back to Episodes

“Scale Welfare: Trying to figure out how to help farmed fish in Southeast Asia” by KvPelt🔹, Ameer Virani🔸

Published 22 hours ago
Description

TLDR

  • We are Scale Welfare, a fish welfare charity incubated by AIM in early 2025, working in the Philippines and Vietnam. This is our first Forum post.
  • Farmed fish welfare has no proven, scalable interventions. In our first 1.5 years we went from scoping and 123 intervention ideas to one pilot: on-farm ice slurry slaughter for tilapia in the Philippines, replacing 5 to 15 hours of live transport.
  • Our main lesson so far: desk research and cheap tests tell you very little about whether an intervention will work. You have to generate your own evidence.
  • Early results for our first pilot are mixed. Tilapia lose outward signs of consciousness within about 11 minutes in ice slurry, but can recover after losing them. A frozen meat supplier with over 180 stores is trialling our protocol in test stores, which is encouraging, but it moved faster than our welfare evidence.
  • Our biggest open question is whether to carry one intervention from research to scale, or specialise in testing. Our current default is to be a testing organisation, using ice slurry as a test case for the later stages.
  • Our 2027 core budget is about 400,000 USD. We have applied to [...]

---

Outline:

(00:14) TLDR

(01:56) Who we are

(02:58) Our first 1.5 years

(03:26) Scoping

(04:11) From 123 ideas to one pilot

(04:37) Cheap tests were not enough

(05:29) The ice slurry pilot

(09:10) Early signs of success

(11:12) Where we fit in the intervention pipeline

(12:34) Our plans and what more funding would do

(12:39) Continue or pivot

(13:58) Funding

(14:59) How to support us

The original text contained 1 footnote which was omitted from this narration.

---

First published:
November 20th, 2026

Source:
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/Ekqa9C56wMthBZFar/scale-welfare-trying-to-figure-out-how-to-help-farmed-fish

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

---

Images from the article:

Our first farmer workshop in Pangasinan, Philippines
Tilapia in a transparent transport truck on its way to market. 5–10% do not survive the journey.
Listen Now