Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Who Were James VI & I and Robert Bellarmine? | Part 1
Description
Who were James VI and I and Robert Bellarmine—and why did their arguments about religion become arguments about the right to rule?
In the first of three Beyond the Text conversations, Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson introduce the king and the cardinal behind one of the early seventeenth century's great disputes over authority, allegiance and conscience.
We explore James's turbulent Scottish childhood, his education under George Buchanan, his distrust of resistance theories and his unusually prolific writing. Turning to Bellarmine, we discuss the Catholic response to the Reformation, the method of scholastic controversy and the pope's claim to indirect power in temporal affairs.
When political authority and spiritual obligation come into conflict, who gets to decide where the boundary lies? The episode closes by setting up the Gunpowder Plot, the Oath of Allegiance and the printed controversy explored in the next instalment.
CHAPTERS
00:00 Welcome and the Ruskin Centre
00:35 Introducing James and Bellarmine
02:48 James's childhood, education and resistance
05:01 No bishop, no king
08:18 James as an author
13:11 Bellarmine and the Catholic Reformation
15:29 Rome, England and religious allegiance
18:29 The Controversies and scholastic argument
21:32 The pope's indirect power
24:36 Conscience and the limits of political authority
28:06 Towards the Gunpowder Plot and the Oath
BOOKS AND IDEAS DISCUSSED
James VI and I: Daemonologie, The True Law of Free Monarchies and Basilikon Doron.
Robert Bellarmine: the Controversies and potestas indirecta.
Jack's Ruskin Centre course:
https://www.ruskincentre.co.uk/reimaginingjustice
Beyond the Text:
https://beyondthetext.co.uk
Essays and reviews:
https://theintellectualhistorian.com
COVER ARTWORK
Design based on the anonymous portrait of Robert Bellarmine (1622–23), Museum Plantin-Moretus, Antwerp; source image via Wikimedia Commons (CC0/public domain).