Episode Details

Back to Episodes
Is AI Making Us More Productive? The Studies Disagree.

Is AI Making Us More Productive? The Studies Disagree.

Published 1 week ago
Description

s artificial intelligence really making us more productive? The evidence is far more contradictory than you might expect.In one experiment, experienced software developers using AI completed their work 19% slower, yet believed they were 20% faster. Another study found that customer service agents increased productivity by 15%. And an experiment involving 640 Kenyan entrepreneurs found no significant improvement in average business performance.So what's going on?I launched an AI research agent to collect empirical studies and company accounts examining AI's impact on productivity, employment, entrepreneurship, and business performance. The resulting inventory contains 82 entries, and the findings raise some fascinating questions.Why does AI help some workers while slowing others down? Are we measuring productivity correctly? What happens when AI improves the quality of decisions without reducing the time required to make them? And what are the risks when policymakers draw conclusions before the evidence is clear?In this Exploring Prosperity audio essay, adapted for YouTube, I examine the research, share my own experience using AI, and consider what these findings could mean for economic growth.CHAPTERS:00:00 Faster, Slower, or Better? The AI Productivity Puzzle00:15 Developers 19% Slower, but Believed They Were 20% Faster00:25 Customer Service Gains and the Kenyan Experiment00:45 Building an Inventory of AI Productivity Research01:25 Erica Groshen and the Challenge of Conflicting Evidence01:50 Three Explanations for the Different Results02:05 Better Accuracy Without Saving Time02:35 When AI Helps, and When It Hurts02:55 Why Experience and Judgment Make a Difference03:15 Why AI Slowed Experienced Developers03:40 Knowing When to Trust AI03:55 Lessons From Wall Street04:20 AI's Potential to Improve Decision-Making04:40 How Better Decisions Could Compound Across the Economy05:00 What AI Has Changed in My Own Work05:15 Can We Trust Our Own Productivity Judgments?05:45 Why the Research Still Needs Scrutiny06:10 The Risks of Premature Policy Conclusions06:35 What the Evidence Suggests About AI's Economic Future07:00 The Importance of Human JudgmentThank you very much to our sponsors:Foundation.xyz: When it comes to protecting your Bitcoin, you shouldn’t have to simply trust the company that made your hardware wallet. Foundation believes in verifiability over reputation. Its firmware and apps are open source, its builds are reproducible, and both Passport Core and Passport Prime have undergone independent hardware security audits. The point isn’t simply that Foundation says its products are secure. It’s that you can verify that for yourself. Learn more about Foundation → https://foundation.xyz/River Financial: If not cold storage for your Bitcoin, I’d highly recommend River for buying and holding- River is engineered to protect your Bitcoin over the long run. Use this link for discounts: https://river.com/signup?r=T7GGAF7GEXPLORE THE RESEARCHFull AI Productivity Research Inventory (82 entries):https://www.exploringprosperity.com/p/ai-productivity-the-research-inventorySelected studies:• METR — Measuring AI's Impact on Experienced Software Developers:https://arxiv.org/html/2507.09089v1• Generative AI at Work — Customer Service Productivity:https://academic.oup.com/qje/article/140/2/889/7990658• AI and Entrepreneurship — Kenyan Business Experiment:https://pubsonline.informs.org/doi/10.1287/mnsc.2024.06909• My interview with Erica Groshen, former Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics:

ABOUT EXPLORING PROSPERITYExploring Prosperity examines how technology, markets, money, and human ingenuity shape our future. Evidence, not cheerleading.Read and subscribe: https://www.exploringprosperity.com#ArtificialIntelligence #AIProductivity #EconomicGrowth



This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit
Listen Now