Episode Details

Back to Episodes
Design Thinking and Critical Thinking, Part 2: What Happens in a Crit

Design Thinking and Critical Thinking, Part 2: What Happens in a Crit

Season 19 Episode 24 Published 1 week, 3 days ago
Description

Send us Fan Mail

Part 2, and this time the question is the word itself. Does “crit” come from critical thinking? The root is the same: the Greek kritikos, the ability to judge and discern — to separate, sift and decide. Criticism, critique and crit all descend from it. As a formal teaching event the crit was popularised in nineteenth-century architectural education at the École des Beaux-Arts, where students pinned up drawings and models before a jury of professors and peers. That is still what happens. And the usual claim is that a crit is critical thinking operationalised in real time, through the medium of space, structure and form.

I am not sure that holds. A crit is the name of an event, not a guarantee of what happens inside it. When a professor theatrically tears up a student’s drawing, is that critical thinking? When the feedback is “I don’t like your plan, it doesn’t seem right” — nobody has learned anything. We have invited critics back and we have quietly not invited others. The useful ones did something different: on a school project in Kampung Kerinchi, a critic raised food security rather than accepting a farm idea for the school as a nice pedagogical gesture. The principles of critical thinking also applies to the architecture design studio crit where — clarity, precision, logic, consistency, depth — alongside the habits a studio demands: intellectual humility, the principle of charity, the suspension of judgment for example, can be discerned from the work shown. And critical thinking is bigger than the crit anyway. It is what you do standing inside a finished building doing a case study visit, realising it does not do what its architect claims.

© 2026 Talk Architecture, Author: Naziaty Mohd Yaacob. Image from the website of the Chicago Architecture Center's six design process steps, by Jen Masengarb

Support the show

Do subscribe for premium content and special features which will help to support and sustain Talk Architecture podcast on a more in-depth explanation on design thesis and processes. These special commentaries and ‘how to’ explanations are valuable insights and knowledge not found elsewhere! 

Listen Now

Love PodBriefly?

If you like Podbriefly.com, please consider donating to support the ongoing development.

Support Us