Episode Details

From the Packernet vault, originally aired May 22, 2026.

Ryan opens with a quick sweep of NFC North schedule optimism, with every content creator from Chicago to Detroit to Minneapolis projecting double-digit wins, despite what Vegas says. But the main event is a full breakdown of the Foss Sports Talk video asking whether Caleb Williams is already a top-5 quarterback in the NFL.

Spoiler: he isn't. Ryan goes line by line through the argument. 47 touchdowns in two years isn't impressive when Lamar had 66 and Burrow had 60 in the same span, and Caleb ranked 14th in touchdowns last season. Durability is a tiebreaker, not a qualifier. And the "future potential" logic applies equally to Cam Ward, Drake Maye, and every other 23-year-old with an arm. Colin Cowherd put Caleb third and Mike Florio agreed, which Ryan takes as further confirmation that Bears fans run on vibes while Packers fans run on data.

Meanwhile, Jordan Love sits 4th in PFF's overall quarterback grades. Caleb, in Ryan's view, isn't even a top-10 quarterback yet. Ryan closes with an open invitation: show him one actual data point that puts Williams in the top 10. He'll wait.

To advertise on this podcast please email: ad-sales@libsyn.com
Or go to: https://advertising.libsyn.com/packernetpodcast
Check out everything I'm building across the Packers and NFL world:
NFL Draft Grades: https://nfldraftgrades.com/
Hashmarks: https://hashmarks.io/