Episode Details
Back to Episodes212. How to Follow Up After Meeting Someone
Description
How do you follow up after a networking event, an interview, or a first conversation so that the connection goes somewhere, without sounding like a pitch?
In this episode of Communicate to Lead, Kele Belton shares one question to ask before you write anything, and four steps for turning a first meeting into a professional relationship that lasts.
Quick Answer
Send a short note that mentions one specific thing you noticed about them, and include one offer of support with nothing attached. Lead with what you noticed, not with what you want.
Most follow-up messages say some version of “It was lovely to meet you, and I look forward to staying connected.” They are polite and warm, and they could have been sent to anyone. As Kele sees it, so much of what arrives in our inboxes now is written with AI that a warm but generic note no longer reads as warm. It reads as automated, and it is easy to ignore.
Follow up with what you noticed about them, not with what you want from them.
— Kele Belton, Episode 212
In This Episode
Kele opens with a story of her own: a part-time coaching role she applied for and did not get. Instead of disappearing after the no, she sent a short, specific reply with an offer of support and nothing attached to it. Listen for what that one email led to over the following months, and for what the relationship did and did not do for her.
From there, she sets two sentences side by side that sound almost identical. One asks the other person to keep an eye out on your behalf. The other offers to do something for them. The difference between them is the thesis of the episode, and it explains why so many follow-up messages go nowhere.
Kele also looks at what AI has changed. A tool can write a polished note in seconds, but it lets you skip the part where you pay attention, and it fills the gap with a guess about what the other person needs. The specific detail you noticed is what shows you paid attention.
What You Will Learn
- Why “Lovely to meet you, looking forward to staying connected,” gives the other person nothing to respond to
- The one question to ask yourself before you follow up with anyone
- How to respond thoughtfully after an interview rejection
- Why AI-written follow-up messages often read as a pitch, and what a tool cannot supply for you
- The four steps for turning a first meeting into a professional relationship
- How to stay in touch without becoming a weight in someone’s inbox, and the test for when contact turns into pestering
Who This Episode Is For
This episode is for women in middle and senior leadership who meet people worth knowing and then let the connection fade, or who have received a no they would still like to turn into a relationship. It is for the leader who wants to build professional relationships that feel like her, not like networking.
Your Action Step
Think of one person you have met in the last few months who is worth knowing and whom you have not followed up with properly, or a no you would still like to turn into a relationship. Ask yourself whether the relationship matters to you. If it does, write one note that includes one specific thing you noticed about them and an offer with nothing attached. If you have already sent the note, find their most recent post and leave a comment worth remembering.
Common Questions About Following Up After Meeting Someone
How do you follow up after a networking event?
Send a short note that mentions one specific thing you discussed and something you appreciated about the person. Add an offer of support with nothing attached. Then connect on LinkedIn and engage thoughtfully with what they post. A message that could have gone to anyone gives the other person nothing to respond to.
What should you say after an interview when you