Episode Details

Back to Episodes
E152| One man’s trash is another’s evidentiary treasure? Cigarette butts, coffee cups & comparative DNA analysis.

E152| One man’s trash is another’s evidentiary treasure? Cigarette butts, coffee cups & comparative DNA analysis.

Season 5 Published 3 weeks, 6 days ago
Description

Provide your feedback here. Anonymously send me a text message.

In this episode, Mike discusses the P.E.I. Supreme Court decision R. v. Gallant, 2026 PESC 31, where police rummaged through a man's trash bin at the end of his driveway, removing cigarette butts and coffee cups. DNA was collected from these items and compared to DNA retrieved from a murder scene more than 30 years earlier, which proved a match. This match was then used to obtain further judicial authorizations. The man was subsequently charged with first degree murder and improperly interfering with human remains. The man sought a court ruling that police breached s. 8 of the Charter — the right to be secure against unreasonable search or seizure — and he wanted the evidence excluded. Did the police conduct amount to an unreasonable search or seizure? Was collecting and analyzing the DNA from the items left in the trash to be used for comparison purposes even a search or seizure? Or did the man abandon any legitimate expectation of privacy in the items and his DNA on it by placing it out for curb side collection? 

PEI Minister of Justice and Public Safety order of an independent review.

Charlottetown Police Services response to Minister's order.

Thanks for listening! Feedback welcome at legalissuesinpolicing@gmail.com

Listen Now

Love PodBriefly?

If you like Podbriefly.com, please consider donating to support the ongoing development.

Support Us