Episode Details
Back to EpisodesLizzie Borden Took An Axe
Description
The Lizzie Borden rhyme is catchy, but it’s also a trap. Two people are murdered inside a modest house on 2nd Street in Fall River on a bright summer morning in 1892, and the person standing at the center of the storm walks away legally cleared. That gap between what we “think” we know and what can actually be proven is where this story gets truly unsettling.
We break down the Borden family dynamic, starting with Andrew Borden’s wealth and extreme frugality, the simmering tension over money and property, and the complicated place Abby holds as a stepmother. From there, we follow the timeline: Abby attacked upstairs, Andrew later killed on the downstairs sofa, and a neighborhood full of people who somehow don’t see anyone flee. Then come the details that made headlines and still fuel debates today: Lizzie’s inconsistent-sounding answers, the burned dress she says was stained with paint, the report that she tried to obtain prussic acid, and the discovery of hatchets in the basement without the kind of forensic science we rely on now.
And because Dark Crossroads lives at the crossroads of true crime and paranormal, we also go into what happens after the trial. The Borden House becomes one of America’s most talked-about haunted locations, with visitors reporting footsteps, voices, cold spots, shifting objects, and apparitions, plus eerie claims tied to Maplecroft. By the end, we’re left with the only honest conclusion: the mystery survives because certainty never arrived.
Subscribe for more true crime and paranormal deep dives, share this with a friend who loves unsolved cases, and leave us a rating and review. What do you think really happened inside the Borden house?
Paris Rhône
Paris Rhône main products include household items, polishers, and coffee grinders.
Please send cases you want covered or stories you want read on the podcast to darkcrossroadspodcast@gmail.com. Don't forget to like, share, rate, review, and subscribe wherever you're listening to us. You can subscribe through the link in the episode notes to receive bonus content, discounts on future merchandise, and other extras.
Be Weird. Stay Different. Don't Trust Anyone!