Episode Details

Imagine stepping into a bar where silent film star Tom Mix once poured drinks, where bullet holes pepper the ceiling, and where the spirits of 1889 might still be watching from the top of the stairs. This week on the Only in OK Show, we're heading to the heart of Guthrie's National Historic Landmark district to explore one of Oklahoma Territory's oldest and most notorious watering holes: the Blue Belle Saloon.

Located at 224 W. Harrison Ave, the Blue Belle is a unique mix of territorial grit, Wild West scandal, and spine-chilling paranormal lore. Join us as we dive into its rich and wild past:

• Wild West Royalty & Bartenders: Founded during the 1889 Land Run by John Selstrom and Jack Tearney, the saloon hosted regular patrons like Temple Houston (son of Sam Houston) and once employed Hollywood cowboy legend Tom Mix behind the bar.

• Architectural Quirks: From its 1903 brick upgrade to the Fred Heim Brewing Co. "C-11" crest and dual beveled entryways, discover what makes this building a stand-out landmark.

• Scandals, Bordellos, & Tunnels: Explore the history of Madame "Miss Lizzie," the upper-floor 17-room bordello, the old iron sky-walk connecting to the Elks Hotel, and rumors of Prohibition-era underground tunnels.

• Hauntings & Urban Legends: From disembodied voices and flying glasses to the spirits of Miss Lizzie, Estelle, and the tragic legend of Claudia, we separate documented history from spooky local lore.

• Exploring Guthrie Today: How you can visit the exterior, spot surrounding historic markers (like the Same Old Moses Saloon), and check out local walking tours.

Listener Questions:

• Would you spend a night alone upstairs in one of those 17 former bordello rooms?

• What do you think makes Guthrie such a massive hotspot for paranormal activity compared to other Oklahoma towns?

Show Notes & Links:

• Learn more about local hauntings with Dust, Death, and Devils: Guthrie Ghost Tour: https://usghostadventures.com/guthrie-ghost-tour/ 

• Also discussed: Think Ability Inc. & KFOR

#OnlyInOKShow #OnlyInOklahoma #GuthrieOK #BlueBelleSaloon #OklahomaHistory #TerritorialOklahoma #GhostTours #HauntedOklahoma #TomMix #WildWestHistory #OkiePodcasts #ExploreOK