Episode Details

Back to Episodes

“Trying to Spend $100m+ Well: My Search for the Perfect Grant Sizing Formula” by Rory Fenton

Published 1 month, 1 week ago
Description

Epistemic status: I’ve puzzled over this for a long time but I’m not sure I came to the right answers. I'm sharing this partly because it might help others work on resource allocation, but mostly because some smarter reader might tell me how to do it better.

TL;DR:

  • I helped set up a large foundation and we wanted a consistent way to allocate grants
  • We planned to allocate substantially more than our field was able to absorb right now, giving us the opportunity to actively shape our field
  • We outlined key principles and considerations
  • We quickly learned we could not just copy the for-profit world: so what could we do?
  • We could try and optimize perfectly, mathematically, but it gets absurd and impractical
  • Instead, we tried out a bunch of different approaches to finding a consistent grant allocation formula, settling on the one that most “felt” right given our starting principles and constraints
  • I quite liked this process of setting principles and constraints, and then vibing your way to an allocate formula that feels right vs being super mathematical
  • I wanted to share this process as a real example of trying to work out how to allocate funding. [...]

---

Outline:

(01:33) x = height of the opposing player

(02:50) Searching for the perfect grant-allocation formula

(03:30) Our core metrics

(04:32) We couldn't just copy from other grantmakers or the for-profit world

(07:46) Turning our principles into a utility function + optimizing

(09:56) "Vibing" our way to a utility function

(10:35) The "Obvious" Option: Allocate by Expected Cost-Effectiveness

(11:38) The "Risk-Buckets" Approach

(12:43) The Kelly Criterion

(14:22) Sharpe ratio

(14:57) Edge

(16:24) What We Actually Did

(17:11) If we settled on edge, doesn't that mean there was a calculable utility function in the background the whole time?

(20:00) What I learned in all of this

The original text contained 1 footnote which was omitted from this narration.

---

First published:
October 8th, 2026

Source:
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/zWTuwxwRdNjSyWuw2/trying-to-spend-usd100m-well-my-search-for-the-perfect-grant

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

---

Images from the article:

A line graph showing a downward-opening parabola peaking near 4.5 at x=3.
A graph showing a downward parabola and a curved green line intersecting near the origin.

Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try

Listen Now