Episode Details
Back to Episodes“CCF: The Spreadsheet in Your Head Is Misallocating Your Giving” by Rethink Priorities, Marcus_A_Davis
Description
Opinion piece by Marcus A. Davis, CEO of Rethink Priorities
TL;DR:
- The problem: Major donors choose between causes like AI safety, global health, and animal welfare without writing down why. In interviews, many couldn’t say what their gifts achieved or how they weighed one cause against another.
- Why it happens: Skipping the spreadsheet feels simpler and more humble, but every gut call is still a model, just one nobody can see or check.
- How it goes wrong: The hidden model makes strong claims by accident. An even split says every cause is equally good at the margin. “I’ll adjust a bit for my doubts” could mean very different strategies. Anything you didn’t think about gets counted as zero. A model you only follow when it agrees with you corrects nothing.
- Why it gets worse with harder questions: Cross-cause decisions are complex and give no feedback, which is exactly when intuition is least reliable, and mistakes are hardest to notice.
- What it costs: Millions can be given with no all-things-considered comparison behind them, so money is likely being misallocated.
- What to do: Small donors can rely on a fund or evaluator. Large donors should pay for in-depth analysis [...]
---
Outline:
(03:09) Congratulations, that was a model
(04:52) The critics of models have a point, but it doesn't prove what they think
(06:19) Leaving it out is the same as counting it as zero
(07:33) Now let's try a harder question
(10:00) "Just adjust a bit" is (hilariously) underspecified
(12:27) "But the numbers are made up"
(14:14) Why not use rules of thumb?
(15:01) It's tempting to only follow models when they agree with you
(15:50) But all of this takes too much effort
(17:08) "I can't follow the model, the model says 'we don't know'"
(17:35) What this means for you
(19:06) Flip the default
(20:44) Acknowledgements
---
First published:
October 8th, 2026
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.
---
Images from the article:
Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.