Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Mega Edition: The Murder Of Suzanne Morphew (10/6/26)
Published 3 hours ago
Description
Suzanne Morphew was a 49-year-old mother of two from Colorado who disappeared from her home near Salida on May 10, 2020, Mother’s Day. She had originally been from Indiana and was married to Barry Morphew, but investigators later uncovered evidence that the marriage had deteriorated and that Suzanne had been considering divorce. Her disappearance triggered an enormous search after she was reported missing when she failed to return messages and plans with family members. Her bicycle was eventually found away from the home, and investigators increasingly focused on Barry, alleging that he killed Suzanne on May 9 and attempted to make her disappearance look like the result of an abduction or bicycle ride gone wrong. Barry denied killing his wife and maintained that someone else could have abducted her. He was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in 2021, but prosecutors dismissed the case without prejudice in April 2022 after serious discovery problems led a judge to restrict key prosecution witnesses, leaving authorities free to bring charges again if additional evidence emerged.
The case changed dramatically in September 2023, when Suzanne’s remains were discovered in a shallow grave near Moffat, Colorado, more than 40 miles from her home. An autopsy subsequently classified her death as a homicide, and investigators found chemicals associated with the wildlife tranquilizer mixture known as BAM in her remains; Barry had experience using tranquilizers while raising deer, and investigators had previously recovered tranquilizer equipment during searches connected to the case. In June 2025, a Colorado grand jury indicted Barry Morphew again for first-degree murder, putting the case back on track for trial. He has continued to maintain his innocence and dispute the prosecution’s theory. As of October 2026, Barry is again in custody after his bond was increased to $10 million following an August 2026 incident, and his murder trial is currently expected in the summer of 2027. Suzanne’s disappearance therefore evolved from one of Colorado’s most closely watched missing-person cases into a homicide prosecution that, more than six years later, is still moving toward a final courtroom reckoning.
The case changed dramatically in September 2023, when Suzanne’s remains were discovered in a shallow grave near Moffat, Colorado, more than 40 miles from her home. An autopsy subsequently classified her death as a homicide, and investigators found chemicals associated with the wildlife tranquilizer mixture known as BAM in her remains; Barry had experience using tranquilizers while raising deer, and investigators had previously recovered tranquilizer equipment during searches connected to the case. In June 2025, a Colorado grand jury indicted Barry Morphew again for first-degree murder, putting the case back on track for trial. He has continued to maintain his innocence and dispute the prosecution’s theory. As of October 2026, Barry is again in custody after his bond was increased to $10 million following an August 2026 incident, and his murder trial is currently expected in the summer of 2027. Suzanne’s disappearance therefore evolved from one of Colorado’s most closely watched missing-person cases into a homicide prosecution that, more than six years later, is still moving toward a final courtroom reckoning.