Episode Details
Back to Episodes“Reasons why far-future civilizations may still greatly value biodiversity” by Tandena Wagner
Description
Many people here have dismissed the value of biodiversity because
-
it's not an x-risk
-
an "ecosystem" does not experience qualia
-
preserving large natural areas often conflicts with both economic growth and with boosting wild animals' welfare
However, if humanity survives to build a flourishing future, it's reasonable to think that the inhabitants of this far-future civilization will greatly value Earth's heritage of biodiversity, similar to how they will likely appreciate cultural & historical artifacts.
(The value derived from biodiversity could be a tiny 0.000001% percentage of total future value, yet at the same time be immense absolute amounts of enjoyment / appreciation / etc, more than we can even comprehend today.)
Previously, I've examined other common justifications for ecological value (ecosystem services + x-risk from ecological collapse) and found that they don't hold much water. I now think that, by relatively standard longtermist arguments, preserving earth's biological richness into the far-future is probably the most important aspect of environmental conservation actions we could take today.
Why would a super-civilization at technological maturity have any use for the highly imperfect products of five billion years' blind evolution? People today intrinsically value biodiversity for many reasons [...]
---
Outline:
(01:50) Variety
(02:26) Irreplaceability
(03:56) Historicity
(05:19) Cost-Disease
(06:27) Conclusion
(06:47) Does this actually affect real-world conservation decisions?
(08:12) Other Potential Sources of Value
(08:18) Animal Preference Utilitarianism
(09:24) Uncertainty about the true system of morality?
(10:18) We just like trees?
(10:53) How much do these values dominate our decisions versus other values?
The original text contained 7 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.
---
First published:
September 28th, 2026
---
Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.