Episode Details

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.

Garage Sale Mysteries is back after six years, and Eric and Andrea review Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage, with Lori Loughlin returning as Jennifer Shannon. Andrea has been waiting for this one for a long time. Eric has spent years saying only one Garage Sale movie was any good. So did the new one change his mind, or did Andrea finally have to admit the series has its limits?

What You'll Hear:

• Andrea's five out of five, which she more or less decided before the opening credits

• Eric's surprisingly generous verdict, plus his reenactment of Jen investigating the dark room alone

• The little details superfans will catch, like the missing corner and the new diner

• How the true crime book club's Lizzie Borden reenactment gave the mystery a full, workable murder board

• Why Eric thinks this one finally delivered real suspects and real red herrings

• Steve Bacic's behind-the-scenes take on how quickly the cast fell back into rhythm

• How the movie worked around Hannah's limited screen time

• Real Lizzie Borden trivia, including what the famous playground rhyme gets wrong

• Hallmark and Chill picks from Murder, She Wrote, Mystery 101, Picture Perfect Mysteries, and Aurora Teagarden

Chapters:

0:00 - Can Garage Sale Mysteries Finally Win Eric Over?

2:00 - That Lizzie Borden Netflix Series (Andrea Lasted 14 Minutes)

4:10 - Practical Magic 2 and a Hunter King Lookalike

5:45 - Plot Enjoyment: Andrea's Five Out of Five

10:15 - Eric's Verdict: Begrudgingly Fantastic

14:05 - The Mystery: Red Herrings That Actually Work

16:55 - Romance Roundup: Jen and Jason

18:30 - Character Corner: Dani vs. Jason

19:45 - Trivia: The Real Lizzie Borden Case

21:55 - Hallmark and Chill Recommendations

23:30 - Next Week: Pumpkin Regatta Romance

Andrea gave it a five, Eric landed somewhere between a four and a four and a half. Where do you land, and did you guess the killer before Jen did?

New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.

#GarageSaleMysteries #MurderTakesTheStage #LoriLoughlin #SteveBacic #SarahStrange #KevinOGrady #LizzieBorden #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyMystery #CozyTV #HallmarkReview

Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website. 

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.