Episode Details
Back to EpisodesSGEM#520: It takes my pain away – Morphine, but do I need to add acetaminophen?
Published 2 months ago
Description
Date: Sept 13, 2026
Caitlin Jones PhD
Guest Skeptic: Dr. Caitlin Jones is a Postdoctoral Research Associate at Sydney University’s Institute for Musculoskeletal Health. Her research evaluates the benefits and harms of treatments for musculoskeletal conditions with a particular interest in high-risk treatment options such as opioid medicines and spinal cord stimulators for pain. She aims to improve patient outcomes and reduce harm from inappropriate treatments.
Reference: Cattin et al. Morphine Plus Placebo vs Morphine Plus Acetaminophen for Acute Pain in the Emergency Department: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Netw Open. 2026 Feb
Case: A 42-year-old otherwise healthy man presents to your emergency department (ED) with eight hours of severe abdominal pain. He rates it as 8/10. His vital signs are normal, Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score is 15 and he weighs 82 kg. He has not taken any analgesics in the previous eight hours and does not use chronic opioids. There is no evidence of acute coronary syndrome, respiratory failure or another immediately unstable condition.
His initial work-up is underway, but he remains visibly uncomfortable. You decide that intravenous (IV) opioid analgesia is appropriate and start titrated morphine. Your resident asks whether adding IV acetaminophen will meaningfully improve his pain control.
Background: Pain is one of the most common reasons patients show up in the ED. Depending on how you measure it, pain is the chief complaint in roughly half of ED visits and is documented somewhere in the chart in about 60% [1]. A large US data set found pain was the primary symptom in approximately 45% of ED visits [2]. So, treating pain is not exactly a niche part of emergency medicine; it is pretty much our bread and butter. Unfortunately, sometimes there is more bread (pain) than butter (pain control).
We have several tools in the analgesic toolbox. Pharmacologic options include acetaminophen, NSAIDs, opioids, ketamine, local anesthetics and condition-specific medications. We can combine treatments as part of a multimodal approach rather than simply increasing the dose of one drug. There are also non-pharmacologic approaches such as ice, heat, elevation, splinting, positioning, distraction and, in selected patients, physical therapy or other supportive strategies. Current guidance generally encourages using non-opioid and non-pharmacologic approaches when appropriate, while reserving opioids for patients in whom the expected benefits outweigh the harms.
The problem is that there is no magic bullet for pain control. We have covered this repeatedly on the SGEM. The practical target is usually to reduce suffering and restore sufficient function to examine, investigate, treat, and safely discharge the patient. The goal should not be to achieve the mythical 0/10 before anyone is allowed to leave the building. As said in The Princess Bride, “Life is pain, Highness. Anyone who says differently is selling something.”
Opioids remain very effective analgesics for some conditions, including severe abdominal pain, and can have an important role in severe acute pain [3]. They also come with baggage. Immediate adverse effects include nausea, vomiting, sedation, dizziness, hypotension and respiratory depression. Longer exposure brings concerns about tolerance, dependence, misuse and overdose, which is why opioid stewardship matters both inside the ED and at discharge.
This is not an argument for undertreating pain; it is an argument for treating it thoughtfully. We are looking for the Goldilocks zone of pain management, not too much but also not too little. The pendulum has swung back and forth over the years between the two extremes.
Clinical Question: In adult ED patients with acute severe traumatic or nontraumatic pain receiving titrated IV morphine, is morphine without acetaminophen noninferior to morphine plus 1 g IV acetaminophen for reducing pain during the first 30 minutes of treatment?
Reference: Catti