Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Our Love Is Here to Stay, Melodic Analysis
Description
Is memorizing a melody the same as understanding it?
And if you can reproduce a melody accurately, does that necessarily mean you have developed the musical skills required to learn another melody independently?
In this Jazz Piano Skills episode, Dr. Bob Lawrence continues the month-long study of George Gershwin's Our Love Is Here to Stay by exploring its melodic architecture.
Building upon the harmonic analysis from the previous lesson, Dr. Lawrence introduces a systematic approach to hearing, discovering, understanding, and performing the melody.
The objective extends far beyond memorizing individual notes.
Students learn to recognize the musical relationships that make melodies understandable, memorable, and transferable to other jazz standards.
Podcast Packets
Illustrations
Lead Sheets
Play Alongs
Forums
Jazz Piano Skills Community
What You'll Discover
- How to learn a jazz standard melody through a systematic educational process
- Why melodic understanding is more valuable than memorizing individual notes
- How to develop ear training by discovering melodies at the piano
- How scales and arpeggios organize melodic movement
- How to identify melodic phrases and important target notes
- How to develop practical fingering and articulation
- How melody relates to the underlying harmonic structure
- How to harmonize a melody using traditional jazz piano voicings
- Why rhythm is essential to melodic expression
- How to perform the same melody in ballad, bossa, and swing settings
- Why imitation and understanding are complementary but different musical skills
- How to reconstruct a melody when memory fails
Is Imitation the Same as Understanding?
Dr. Lawrence continues a four-part educational discussion titled How Do We Actually Learn Jazz?
This week's question examines the relationship between imitation and musical understanding.
Listening to great jazz musicians, studying recordings, transcribing solos, and reproducing musical phrases are valuable educational experiences.
However, reproducing a musical idea does not automatically demonstrate an understanding of the relationships that make the idea work.
A student may successfully transcribe and memorize a phrase by Oscar Peterson, practice it in twelve keys, and perform it accurately.
But can that student recognize the underlying musical relationships?
Can the phrase be simplified, expanded, rhythmically altered, or adapted to a different harmonic environment?
Can the student use those principles to create something original?
Dr. Lawrence explains that imitation can provide an important doorway into understanding.
The educational objective is to progress from imitation to analysis, understanding, manipulation, creation, and ultimately personal musical expression.
The Eight-Step Melodic Analysis Process
Jazz Piano Skills organizes melodic study around eight essential steps:
- Hear It: Listen carefully to the melody before attempting to reproduce it.
- Find It: Use your ear and musical understanding to discover the melody at the piano.
- Verify It: Confirm the notes and rhythmic relationships through careful analysis.
- Finger It: Develop practical fingerings that support articulation and musical fluency.
- Phrase It: Organize the melody into meaningful musical statements.
- Target It: Identify important destination notes within each melodic phrase.