Episode Details

Melanie Gibb’s testimony was some of the most damaging evidence against Lori Vallow because she described, from inside Lori and Chad Daybell’s circle, how their increasingly radical belief system developed alongside the deaths of people they considered obstacles. Gibb testified that Lori and Chad believed people could become “dark,” possessed by evil spirits or transformed into “zombies,” and she identified Charles Vallow, Tylee Ryan, JJ Vallow and Tammy Daybell as people who had been given those labels before they died. She said Lori believed she and Chad had been married in past lives, were spiritually chosen to lead the 144,000 and could perform “castings” to drive evil spirits from people. Gibb also testified that Lori’s relationship with Chad increasingly distracted her from caring for JJ and that Lori claimed JJ had become possessed, even though Gibb personally saw nothing abnormal about his behavior. Gibb described a disturbing pattern in which people who questioned Lori, became suspicious of her or stood in the way of her relationship with Chad suddenly became labeled dark or zombie.

Gibb also placed herself at the center of one of the prosecution’s most important pieces of evidence: Lori’s effort to conceal JJ’s disappearance. When police came looking for JJ in November 2019, Lori falsely told them that he was staying with Gibb in Arizona. Gibb initially repeated part of that lie to police, then became alarmed and eventually contacted investigators. She secretly recorded a December 2019 phone call in which she confronted Lori and Chad about JJ’s whereabouts, telling Lori that what was happening did not feel like “God’s plan.” Lori refused to reveal where JJ was and insisted he was safe, while Chad accused Gibb of being influenced by dark forces. Gibb also testified that Alex Cox later told her she did not want to know what had happened to JJ. Her testimony gave jurors a firsthand account of the progression from fringe religious beliefs to deception about missing children, while showing that Lori was actively constructing false explanations for JJ’s whereabouts after prosecutors said he was already dead and buried on Chad Daybell’s property.



to contact me:


bobbycapucci@protonmail.com