Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Mega Edition: The Lawyer, The New York Times And The Mysterious Man (9/14/26)
Published 4 days, 5 hours ago
Description
The story begins with a shadowy figure using the alias “Patrick Kessler,” who contacted high-profile lawyers claiming he had access to an encrypted archive of Epstein’s surveillance footage — including videos allegedly implicating powerful individuals. Kessler persuaded respected attorneys like David Boies and John Pottinger to engage with him, proposing schemes in which those incriminated would pay large private settlements (some proceeds earmarked for victims) to keep the footage hidden. The lawyers—even while representing Epstein’s accusers—were accused of attempting to profit by holding this “evidence” hostage. Over months of negotiations, The New York Times was brought in as a possible media outlet to pressure the men on the so-called “hot list.” But none of the promised videos ever materialized, and Kessler later claimed his servers were destroyed in a fire, forcing him to flee.
Critics argue that Boies’s deep involvement in the Kessler scheme blurred ethical lines: a lawyer advocating for victims who also appeared poised to monetize secret evidence placed him in a conflicted position. The Times, meanwhile, has been faulted for its handling of the story—reporting Kessler’s claims without sufficiently flagging how unverified they were, or how they played into an opportunistic playbook of legal maneuvering over actual justice. Some see the Kessler-Boies-Times saga as illustrative of how even institutions considered pillars of integrity can become complicit in obfuscation, leveraging sensational claims for influence rather than holding the powerful accountable.
Former Palm Beach County sheriff’s deputy John Mark Dougan made a separate but related set of claims about alleged Epstein recordings. Dougan said a Palm Beach detective connected to the original Epstein investigation, Joseph Recarey, had allowed him to copy investigative material for safekeeping and that Dougan eventually possessed a hard drive containing hundreds of alleged Epstein recordings. He later claimed there were hundreds of tapes, possibly including compromising footage involving Prince Andrew and other prominent people, and said the FBI seized his computers during a 2016 raid but did not realize he had retained a copy that later ended up with him in Russia. Journalist Craig Unger reported that Dougan told him he possessed 478 Epstein sex tapes, while Dougan himself has repeatedly suggested Epstein’s properties were wired for systematic blackmail. But despite years of making those claims, Dougan has never publicly produced authenticated footage establishing that he possesses what he says he does. That leaves his story in a very different category from the documented evidence that Epstein used extensive surveillance at his properties: the existence of surveillance is well established, while Dougan’s claim that he personally holds hundreds of explosive sex tapes remains unverified.
to contact me:
bobbycapucci@protonmail.com
Critics argue that Boies’s deep involvement in the Kessler scheme blurred ethical lines: a lawyer advocating for victims who also appeared poised to monetize secret evidence placed him in a conflicted position. The Times, meanwhile, has been faulted for its handling of the story—reporting Kessler’s claims without sufficiently flagging how unverified they were, or how they played into an opportunistic playbook of legal maneuvering over actual justice. Some see the Kessler-Boies-Times saga as illustrative of how even institutions considered pillars of integrity can become complicit in obfuscation, leveraging sensational claims for influence rather than holding the powerful accountable.
Former Palm Beach County sheriff’s deputy John Mark Dougan made a separate but related set of claims about alleged Epstein recordings. Dougan said a Palm Beach detective connected to the original Epstein investigation, Joseph Recarey, had allowed him to copy investigative material for safekeeping and that Dougan eventually possessed a hard drive containing hundreds of alleged Epstein recordings. He later claimed there were hundreds of tapes, possibly including compromising footage involving Prince Andrew and other prominent people, and said the FBI seized his computers during a 2016 raid but did not realize he had retained a copy that later ended up with him in Russia. Journalist Craig Unger reported that Dougan told him he possessed 478 Epstein sex tapes, while Dougan himself has repeatedly suggested Epstein’s properties were wired for systematic blackmail. But despite years of making those claims, Dougan has never publicly produced authenticated footage establishing that he possesses what he says he does. That leaves his story in a very different category from the documented evidence that Epstein used extensive surveillance at his properties: the existence of surveillance is well established, while Dougan’s claim that he personally holds hundreds of explosive sex tapes remains unverified.
to contact me:
bobbycapucci@protonmail.com