Episode Details
Back to Episodes
The PR News Review: The Harry and Meghan show, 9/11 tribute, The RNLI and Anthropic's Whistleblower
Description
This edition of the PRmoment News Review, hosted by Ben Smith with Angie Moxham and Mark Borkowski, worked through four stories that each turned on the same question: what communications can and cannot fix.
The Sussexes opened the show, and both guests pushed back hard on the week's dominant narrative. Borkowski said he felt "incredibly sorry" for the couple's comms team and rejected the theory that their PR is incompetent — the problem, he argued, is a client who defines the work and then cannot be advised.
Moxham agreed, calling the adviser role a poisoned chalice and the succession of departures a revolving door.
Both located the fault in the principals and the institution rather than in the consultants. Borkowski's prescription was counterintuitive: the only tactic the couple have never tried is silence. A quiet return, he suggested, would have surprised everyone; instead they chose visibility, and the King's statement this week poured cold water on any reading of the trip as coordinated reconciliation.
On the RNLI, the panel was unequivocal about the Portsmouth protests. Moxham called the scenes disgraceful, noted the charity has offered volunteers the option of removing the badge, and directed blame at both protesters and government.
Borkowski set the images in a longer political frame — black shirts and balaclavas evoking Oswald Mosley — while pointing out that small-boat crossings are reportedly down 40%.
His communications concern was practical: if the controversy damages the RNLI's fundraising, coastal safety suffers. He also used the segment to make the episode's broadest point, urging comms professionals to remember how algorithmic feeds shape which version of the migration story each audience receives, and how much of Middle England is genuinely uneasy.
The 9/11 anniversary drew the show's most provocative argument. Borkowski repeated a position that once landed him in hot water: the attacks were, in his reading, the darkest and most effective publicity stunt ever staged, engineered around a twenty-minute gap so cameras were pointed at the first tower when the second plane hit. Moxham spoke more personally about the tribute's power and the unresolved health legacy of the Manhattan dust.
Finally, Anthropic. Borkowski read the whistleblower's 10% extinction claim as a genuine wake-up call rather than a stunt; Moxham was more cynical, tying it to AI valuations and a possible IPO, while arguing governments have not built any real accountability framework. Both landed on regulation being unlikely in the current US political climate — a short conversation, as Moxham put it.
Here is a selection of quotes from this week's show:
Mark Borkowski on Harry & Meghan
"I'm going to step out and say I feel incredibly sorry for their comms team. There seems to be this theory that they've got incompetent PR, and I don't think they've got incompetent PR at all."
"If you keep on doing the same thing time and time again, expecting a different outcome, that's a definition of madness. They need to do something that they have never done before, and that is stay incredibly quiet."
Angie Moxham on Harry & Meghan
"It's a poisoned chalice being their advisers, because they clearly don't take advice. They've had some good people in there. It's been a revolving door."
On the RNLI bringing migrants ashore and the civil unrest in Portsmouth
Angie Moxham "These people risk their lives day in, day out to help people struggling at sea. Shame on the protesters, and shame on the government."
Mark Borkowski
"The image of those black shirts — it was like Oswald Mosley is back again, thuggish blokes with balaclavas on — has had a profound effect."
"If it affects their ability to raise the money, God knows how we can all be safe on the coast."
Mark Borkowski on Media & Algorithms
Listen Now
Love PodBriefly?
If you like Podbriefly.com, please consider donating to support the ongoing development.
Support Us