Episode Details

Dr. Michael Baden, forensic psychologist Joni Johnston and criminal profiler John Kelly were among the experts who weighed in publicly as investigators tried to make sense of the University of Idaho murders before the full case against Bryan Kohberger was known. Baden focused heavily on the physical crime scene and the likely use of a large fixed-blade knife, explaining that the wounds, blood patterns and condition of the victims could help investigators determine the sequence of the attacks, whether the killer had been injured and whether DNA or other trace evidence had been left behind. He also emphasized that a crime involving four stabbing victims would have been physically demanding and extremely difficult to carry out without transferring biological evidence somewhere along the way. Johnston examined the behavioral side of the case, discussing the possibility that the killer had selected the house or one of the victims beforehand and stressing that the apparently targeted nature of the attack suggested planning rather than a completely random burst of violence.

Kelly similarly approached the case through behavioral profiling, arguing that the killer likely had some degree of familiarity with the residence, the victims or their routines because moving through a dark, multi-level house and attacking four people carried enormous risk. He suggested that the offender may have rehearsed the crime mentally, watched the house or otherwise prepared before entering, and that the brutality of the killings could point to obsession, anger, fantasy or a desire for control. All three experts cautioned, in different ways, that early profiling could only go so far without access to the full crime-scene evidence. Their commentary nevertheless reflected the central questions investigators were confronting at the time: why that house was chosen, whether one person was the primary target, how the killer managed to move through the residence, what physical evidence was left behind and whether the attack represented a long-developing fixation rather than a spontaneous act.


to contact me:


bobbycapucci@protonmail.com