Episode Details

Send us Fan Mail

Easter weekend, 1980. A Catholic nun walks into a chapel to prepare for Easter Sunday—and never makes it home.

Sister Margaret Ann Pahl was just 71 years old when she was brutally murdered inside the chapel of Toledo’s Mercy Hospital. For decades, her death remained unsolved, leaving behind a case filled with unanswered questions, a shocking crime scene, and a killer who managed to stay free for far too long.

But after nearly four decades, investigators finally got the break they needed.

In this episode of Thick Thighs and Murder Vibes, we’re diving into the murder of Sister Margaret Ann Pahl, the investigation that refused to die, and the twist that finally brought her killer to justice.

So grab your snacks, settle in, and prepare for some Holy Hell—because this case is a reminder that sometimes justice takes its sweet-ass time… but it doesn't always forget.