Episode Details
Back to EpisodesSGEM Xtra: If I Could Turn Back Time – 14 Seasons of Skepticism, Kindness & Evidence-Based EM
Published 2 months, 2 weeks ago
Description
Date: September 4, 2026
This is an SGEM Xtra looking in the rearview mirror at 14 years of The SGEM and looking forward to Season#15. Season 15 is traditionally the crystal anniversary. Crystal is transparent; it can help us see things more clearly, and it can also shatter if you drop it. So, basically, a great metaphor for medical evidence.
Cue some 80s music. Because if I could turn back time. Unfortunately, I don’t have a DeLorean, a flux capacitor, or 1.21 gigawatts. What I do have is a microphone, a large collection of papers, and what may be an unhealthy willingness to discuss p-values and confidence intervals.
PICOT for this SGEM Xtra Episode:
Population: SGEMers
Intervention: 14 years of skeptical knowledge translation
Comparison: Practising emergency medicine before the SGEM
Outcome: Thinking better leading to better care
Type of Study: Not really a study, but more of an unblinded observation, heavily confounded by nostalgia, that has been funded primarily by enthusiasm and coffee.
When the SGEM began, the goal was straightforward but ambitious: to shorten the knowledge-translation window from more than 10 years to less than 1 year with the power of social media. We wanted to identify clinically relevant emergency medicine research, critically appraise it, and deliver that information to the front-line clinicians caring for patients. Medical education for anyone, anywhere, at any time. Very similar to the EM philosophy of seeing anyone, anytime, for anything. Listen to the podcast and turn your car into a classroom. That was the idea.
I am very thankful to my evidence-based medicine (EBM) mentor, Dr. Andrew Worster from McMaster University. He started the BEEM project and took a chance on me about 20 years ago. Andrew also taught me the EBM answer of “it all depends”. I pitched the idea to him in ~2011 about doing a podcast while riding a ski lift at the Silver Star ski resort in BC. He said…what’s a podcast? Andrew also suggested I attend the University of Oxford and take a mini-fellowship course from the Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine (CEBM) on how to teach EBM. My idea was to create a blog and podcast to encourage skepticism, critical thinking and demonstrate how to review a publication. That is how this whole thing got started.
There was no five-year strategic plan, no glossy prospectus and no venture-capital funding. There was a blog, a podcast, social media, a standardized critical-appraisal process adopted from the BEEM group, and a growing group of people who believed emergency clinicians deserved timely access to the best available evidence. It was fortunate that it happened at the same time as the Free Open Access to Medical Education (FOAMed) movement was launched in 2012.
Not the newest evidence simply because it was new. Not the loudest evidence because someone had a good marketing department. And not the most prestigious evidence merely because it appeared in a high-impact journal. As I like to say, the only thing you can conclude when something is published in the NEJM is that it was published in the NEJM. All your work to determine its validity is still in front of you.
The goal was to find and critically appraise the emergency medicine literature, interpret it in the context of clinical expertise and what matters to individual patients. Fourteen seasons later, the SGEM has more than 85,000 subscribers. It has been translated into five languages, and more than 100 SGEM critical appraisals have been published in peer-reviewed journals.
Those numbers are wonderful, and I am very proud of them. But numbers can only tell part of the story. I don’t want this to be an argument from popularity. A download does not tell you whether someone reconsidered an old habit. A subscriber count cannot capture the moment a clinician paused before ordering a low-value test, questioned an impressive relative risk rather than considering the absolute risk reduction, or had a better shared decision-m