Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Deb McCluskey: From Lilβs Cafe to 7 Restaurants | Ep. 71 Beyond The Plate Podcast
Description
Deb McCluskey bought one small cafe in Kittery, Maine in 2021. Five years later, she and her son Michael McCluskey run seven restaurants across Maine and New Hampshire -- and she signed the lease on the seventh one without telling him.
Carol Erickson sat down with Deb inside Salty Spirits, the 500-square-foot oyster and cocktail bar in Kittery Foreside with just 14 seats at the bar, to walk through all seven concepts one by one: Lil's Cafe and its famous crullers in Kittery, the Islander Cafe on the water in New Castle, New Hampshire, Stella's Cafe in Dover, June's Cafe in Newmarket, Henry's Bagel and Deli on Route 1, Salty Spirits, and Dudley Street Pizza.
Deb talks about frying donuts alongside her grandmother, washing dishes at 14, the fifteen years she spent working for Michael Landgarten before buying Lil's from him in the middle of COVID, why Henry's has no espresso machine, how an entire raw bar menu gets made in one toaster oven, and the year her son got seriously ill while three brand new restaurants were opening. Carol brings nearly 40 years of her own diner experience to the table, and the two of them land somewhere real about what regulars actually mean to a family-owned restaurant.
π Salty Spirits -- 76 Wallingford Square, Kittery, ME
π saltyspiritskittery.com | lilscafe.com | junescafenh.com
Lil's Cafe (Kittery, ME) | Henry's Bagel and Deli (Kittery, ME) | Dudley Street Pizza (Kittery, ME) | Islander Cafe (New Castle, NH) | Stella's Cafe (Dover, NH) | June's Cafe (Newmarket, NH)
Carol Erickson has spent nearly 40 years in the hospitality industry as the longtime owner of the Red Arrow Diner and its four New Hampshire locations, open 24 hours a day. Alongside the diners, she hosts Beyond the Plate with Carol, a New Hampshire-based podcast covering food, restaurants, and hospitality all across New England. Every episode, Carol sits down with the chefs, entrepreneurs, content creators, and everyday people with an interesting New England story to tell -- from family-owned restaurants and food trucks to multi-concept operators like Deb McCluskey. It's not just about the food -- it's about the journeys, the community, and what drives people to go beyond.
This episode is sponsored by Belmont Hall & Restaurant.
Manchester, NH -- family-owned for over 90 years.
belmonthall.net | Instagram: @belmonthallandcatering | Facebook: @belmonthallandcatering
π New episodes drop every Tuesday -- hit SUBSCRIBE and turn on notifications so you never miss one!
Find Beyond the Plate everywhere: linktr.ee/BeyondtheplateNH
0:00 - Intro
0:12 - Live from Salty Spirits
0:54 - Frying donuts with her grandmother
1:21 - Dishwasher at 14
2:52 - The six months she regretted
3:32 - Buying Lil's during COVID
6:47 - How the Foreside grew up
8:58 - The Islander Cafe in New Castle
12:33 - The cruller recipe that never changed
14:36 - Through the kitchen to the bathroom
16:42 - A record store in a bank vault
20:46 - Stella's Cafe and Lilian's middle name
26:34 - June's and the 130-year-old building
31:41 - Belmont Hall & Restaurant
32:30 - Henry's Bagel and Deli
37:37 - Michael's ten-year oyster bar dream
42:28 - One toaster oven, whole menu
43:34 - "No new businesses" π
48:04 - Signing the lease in secret π
50:29 - Andrew takes over at Lil's
52:05 - Regulars who become family
53:33 - "Do you know my name?" π
54:54 - Lightning Round
1:00:25 - The triple vegetable guy
1:04:20 - Closing thoughts