Episode Details

The controversy over Prince Andrew’s position as a Counsellor of State came from the gap between what the law still allowed him to do and what the Royal Family said would happen in practice. Counsellors of State are senior royals who can be authorized to carry out certain constitutional duties for the monarch when the King is abroad or temporarily unable to act. Even after Andrew stepped back from public duties, lost the use of his HRH style and later had his remaining titles and honours stripped from official use, he technically remained eligible to serve as a Counsellor of State because that status was tied to his place in the line of succession and the statutory framework governing the role. Parliament addressed concerns about the pool of available counsellors in 2022 by adding Princess Anne and Prince Edward, but it did not formally remove Andrew. The government’s position was that only working members of the Royal Family would actually be called upon, meaning Andrew remained on the books but was effectively frozen out.

That arrangement became increasingly awkward as scrutiny of Andrew’s relationship with Jeffrey Epstein intensified. Critics argued that it made little constitutional sense for someone who had been stripped of royal responsibilities and sidelined from public life to retain, even theoretically, the ability to exercise functions on behalf of the King. The issue became even more pronounced after further action was taken against Andrew’s titles and after renewed calls emerged to remove him from the line of succession altogether. Yet formally changing his Counsellor of State status would require legislative action rather than simply a palace announcement, and the government repeatedly resisted reopening the law, relying instead on the assurance that Andrew would never actually be asked to act. The result was an unusually uncomfortable compromise: Andrew retained a constitutional office in theory while being considered completely unusable in practice, a situation that critics saw as another example of the monarchy and government avoiding a clean legal break with him.


to contact me:

bobbycapucci@protonmail.com