Episode Details

Send us Fan Mail

This episode discusses an active criminal investigation. Some information presented is based on law-enforcement statements and reporting from multiple news organizations and may change as investigators review additional evidence. Eugene Horsch has not been charged with the deaths of the missing women discussed in this episode, and allegations should not be interpreted as findings of guilt.

A routine-sounding call near Independence National Historical Park in Philadelphia turns into something far darker when a U.S. park ranger approaches a parked BMW and hears a woman say, “You’re gonna hurt me.” From there, investigators zero in on Eugene Horsch and a trail of reported evidence that escalates fast: illegal firearms, obliterated serial numbers, fraudulent federal law enforcement credentials, and links to a missing woman’s identification. What starts as a stop becomes a widening investigation that lands at a house on West Chew Avenue in the Olney neighborhood and refuses to stay contained. 

We walk through what police have publicly said they found during weeks of searches at the Chew Avenue property, including ammunition, narcotics, chemicals, containers, and urns believed to contain cremated remains, plus extensive digital media storage. Then we slow down and talk about the difficult context investigators have to untangle, including the history of Eugene’s father, Raymond Charles “RC” Horsch, whose background as a photographer, filmmaker, and writer involved sexually explicit and violent imagery. That context doesn’t excuse anything, but it matters when investigators must separate fictional shock material from potential documentation of real harm. 

The most gut-punching turn is digital forensics. Police report recovering roughly 600,000 images, 70,000 videos, and more than 10,000 pages of writings and drawings, while having reviewed only about 5% at the time of their latest update. Investigators say they identified missing women Maribel Fraces and Gabrielle on footage that appears to show them alive inside the house and later appearing deceased, opening a death investigation even though bodies have not been recovered. We talk about why proving a homicide without remains is so hard, why internet speculation can damage real cases, and what questions still have to be answered before anyone can responsibly claim they “know” what happened. 

If you care about ethical true crime, careful reporting, and following the facts where they lead, hit play, then subscribe, share the episode, and leave a review so more listeners can find the show. What’s the first question you want investigators to answer next?

Sources:

Philadelphia Police Department
Official statements and August 12–13, 2026 press briefing regarding the investigation, digital evidence, missing women, search warrants, and death investigation.
6abc / WPVI Action News
“Images from home on West Chew Avenue in Olney appeared to show 2 missing women dead, Philadelphia police say”
By 6abc Digital Staff, John Paul, Amanda Pitts and Elizabeth Worthington
August 13, 2026
6abc / WPVI Action News — Article
NBC10 Philadelphia
“‘Graphic' videos at Olney house show 2 missing women believed dead, police say”
By Emily Rose Grassi and David Charns
August 12–13, 2026
NBC10 Philadelphia — Article
CBS News Philadelphia
“‘Graphic and dark’ evidence found inside Olney home suggests 2 missing women are dead, Philadelphia police say”
By Laura Fay, Joe Holden, Tom Gardiner and CBS News Philadelphia staff
August 12, 2026
CBS News Philadelphia — Article
CBS News Philadelphia
“Detectives looked for evidence of wet cremation at house in Philadelphia's Olney neighborhood, sources say”
By Joe Holden
July 28, 2026
CBS News Philadelphia — Article
CBS News Philadelphia
“Poli