Episode Details

James Fry was the chief of the Moscow Police Department when Madison Mogen, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin were murdered at 1122 King Road on November 13, 2022, making him one of the central law-enforcement figures in the investigation that followed. Fry had worked for the Moscow Police Department since 1993 and became chief in 2016, years before his relatively small department was suddenly confronted with one of the most closely watched murder investigations in the country. Under Fry, Moscow police remained the lead agency while working with the Idaho State Police and FBI, eventually bringing together roughly 130 law-enforcement personnel as investigators processed the crime scene, collected thousands of tips, reviewed surveillance footage, traced a white Hyundai Elantra and developed the forensic evidence that ultimately pointed toward Bryan Kohberger. Fry also became the public face of the investigation, appearing repeatedly at press conferences and attempting to reassure a frightened community while protecting evidence investigators believed could not yet be released. He later acknowledged that the department should have communicated with the public sooner, particularly after waiting several days to hold its first major news conference.


Fry’s handling of the case drew both criticism and praise, especially during the seven weeks between the murders and Kohberger’s December 30, 2022 arrest in Pennsylvania. Families, reporters and members of the public repeatedly demanded more information, while speculation exploded online about potential suspects, stalkers, surviving roommates, the murder weapon and whether the killer remained in Moscow. Fry maintained that investigators were deliberately withholding certain details because releasing them could jeopardize the case, and after Kohberger’s arrest it became clearer how much investigative work had been occurring outside public view. Fry later estimated that during those seven weeks he had only four days off, while members of his department worked similarly demanding schedules. His importance to the Moscow murders therefore extended beyond being the police chief who appeared before the cameras: he supervised the local department responsible for the case, coordinated an enormous influx of state and federal resources, managed an unprecedented level of national attention and helped guide an investigation that moved from a seemingly suspect-less quadruple homicide to the identification and arrest of Bryan Kohberger. Fry remained Moscow’s police chief until May 2024, leaving the department after more than three decades of service.


to contact me:

bobbycapucci@protonmail.com