Episode Details
Back to EpisodesSGEM#517 : I Will Try to Fix You. Surgery or Not for Pediatric Displaced Medial Epicondyle Elbow Fractures
Published 3 months, 1 week ago
Description
Reference: Perry DC, et al. Surgical fixation versus non-surgical care for children with a displaced medial epicondyle fracture of the elbow (the SCIENCE study): a multicentre, randomised controlled, superiority trial and economic evaluation. The Lancet 2026
Date: July 14, 2026
Guest Skeptics: Dr. Megan Terle is an orthopedic surgeon and Assistant Professor for Pediatrics and Trauma services at UC Davis Health. She completed her orthopedics residency at the University of Washington and completed two fellowships, one in pediatrics at the University of Washington and one in trauma at UC Davis.
Dr. Megan Terle
Dr. Holly Leshikar is also an orthopedic surgeon and Associate Professor for Pediatrics and Trauma services at UC Davis Health. She completed orthopedics residency at UC Davis and a pediatric orthopedic surgery fellowship at Vanderbilt Children’s Hospital in Nashville.
Case: An 11-year-old gymnast comes to the emergency department (ED) after a fall from the bars. She felt a “pop” in the elbow and now refuses to move the arm. The elbow is swollen and tender on your examination. You perform a careful neurovascular exam and note intact distal perfusion and no neurological deficits. You temporarily immobilize the arm and order radiographs.
X-ray shows a displaced medial epicondyle fracture. Her parent asks you: “Does she need surgery to put the bone back where it belongs?”
Dr. Holly Leshikar
Background: Medial epicondyle fractures are pediatric elbow injuries involving the bony prominence on the inside of the distal humerus. In children, this area is a secondary growth center. The typical mechanism is an avulsion injury from valgus stress at the elbow, often after a fall onto an outstretched hand or a sports-related injury. These fractures are extra-articular in most cases, but they can be associated with elbow dislocation and, occasionally, the fragment can become trapped inside the joint.
Key early priorities are pain control, neurovascular assessment, recognition and reduction of any elbow dislocation, and post-reduction imaging to ensure the medial epicondyle fragment is not incarcerated in the joint.
Management has traditionally varied widely. Minimally displaced fractures are usually treated non-operatively with immobilization, often in an above-elbow backslab or cast with the elbow flexed around 900. Surgery, usually open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) with a screw or wires, has generally been reserved for clearer indications such as an incarcerated fragment, open fracture, ulnar nerve entrapment, gross elbow instability, or selected high-demand upper extremity athletes.
The real controversy has been the isolated displaced fracture. Supporters of ORIF argue that surgery restores anatomy, improves the reliability of healing, improves stability, and speeds return to activity. Observational studies have supported both approaches, driving uncertainty. Pediatric orthopedics has historically had few clinical trials, leaving decisions shaped by tradition, expert opinion, and retrospective data. Much of the older literature on the medial epicondyle has methodological limitations (e.g., follow-up issues, selection bias, limited patient-reported outcomes).
One smaller RCT from Finland (n=72) suggested non-operative care was non-inferior at 1 year, but a single small trial still left uncertainty.
Clinical Question: In children (age 7 to 15 years) with a displaced medial epicondyle fracture, does surgical fixation improve patient-important outcomes compared with non-surgical immobilization, and is it cost-effective?
Reference: Perry DC, et al. Surgical fixation versus non-surgical care for children with a displaced medial epicondyle fracture of the elbow (the SCIENCE study): a multicentre, randomised controlled, superiority trial and economic evaluation. The Lancet 2026
This was the same lead author as the FORCE trial covered in SGEM #372 that taught us it is reasonable to treat a buckle fracture of th