Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Your Donors Aren’t Tired of You. . . .They’re Tired of This.
Description
How often should nonprofits ask for donations without exhausting their supporters? This Fundraisers Friday conversation offers a sharper way to evaluate donor communication frequency, campaign volume, stewardship, segmentation, and the messages being sent between solicitations!
Julia C. Patrick and Tony Beall challenge a common assumption: frequent communication is not automatically the problem. Tony tells us, “It’s not really that you’re communicating too much. It’s just that what you’re communicating is redundant.”
That distinction matters as nonprofit teams plan GivingTuesday, year-end fundraising, direct mail, email campaigns, social media, and Q4 donor outreach. Eight messages may feel excessive internally, but they may reach several carefully segmented audiences rather than landing repeatedly with the same people.
The lively convo moves beyond campaign calendars into the operating systems that support stronger donor relationships. Tony recommends using volunteers as communication auditors, scheduling dedicated stewardship time, documenting meaningful touchpoints in the CRM, and reviewing the last 10 communications sent through each channel.
One of the most useful ideas is to stop treating donor communication preferences as an all-or-nothing project. Instead of attempting to customize every interaction for every donor, begin with the top 10% of supporters. Learn whether they prefer email, text, phone calls, or direct mail, then expand the process as capacity allows.
Tony also shares a simple phrase that can lower anxiety before a larger solicitation: “How would you feel if…?” Rather than immediately requesting a $20,000 commitment or increased gift, the fundraiser can explore the donor’s reaction and readiness. It opens a candid conversation without cornering the donor—or the fundraiser.
This episode offers a disciplined way to examine whether their organization is communicating too much, too little, or simply without enough variety and relevance.
Key Takeaways:
Segment audiences before judging whether campaign frequency is excessive.
Monitor unsubscribes, nonresponse, and message repetition—not volume alone.
Schedule stewardship activities instead of hoping time appears for them.
Record personal donor touchpoints in the CRM to protect institutional knowledge.
Begin communication-preference tracking with the top 10% of donors.
Audit the last 10 messages in every channel for balance, value, and repeated asks.
00:00:00 Asking Too Often—or Not Enough?
00:03:23 Frequency Versus Donor Fatigue
00:04:47 Why Audience Segmentation Changes the Answer
00:05:45 The Warning Signs of Overcommunication
00:06:17 Using Volunteers as Communication Auditors
00:08:10 Stewardship Between Fundraising Campaigns
00:10:39 Scheduling Time for Thank-You Notes
00:12:33 Delivering Value Without Making an Ask
00:16:13 Why Every Donor Touchpoint Belongs in the CRM
00:18:03 Tracking Communication Preferences Without Overload
00:20:37 “How Would You Feel If?”—A Better Donor Prompt
00:23:46 Audit Your Last 10 Communications
#TheNonprofitShow #NonprofitFundraising #DonorEngagement
Find us Live daily on YouTube!
Find us Live daily on LinkedIn!
Find us Live daily on X: @Nonprofit_Show
Our national co-hosts and amazing guests discuss management, money and missions of nonprofits!
12:30pm ET 11:30am CT 10:30am MT 9:30am PT
Send us your ideas for Show Guests or Topics: HelpDesk@AmericanNonprofitAcad