Episode Details

Send us Fan Mail

A house stuffed with leaves sounds like a joke until SWAT opens the door and realizes the piles aren’t just weird, they’re dangerous. We travel to Mount Vernon, Ohio to unpack the Matthew Hoffman “Leaf Killer” case, a true crime story where a missing persons call turns into one of the strangest crime scenes we’ve ever covered. Bags of leaves stacked floor to ceiling, dead squirrels in the freezer, and a basement hiding a kidnapped 13-year-old girl bound on a literal bed of leaves. 

We walk through how Tina Herrmann disappears, why her boss’s concern matters, and how a second look at the home reveals blood and clear signs of a struggle. From there, the timeline tightens: Tina, her friend Stephanie Sprang, and Tina’s children are suddenly missing, and investigators have to decide whether they’re dealing with a runaway, an accident, or something far worse. We also dig into the theory that Hoffman started as a burglar and then escalated when confronted, turning a break-in into murder and abduction. 

Then we get into the investigative details that help police build the case fast: a Walmart bag with a tarp and heavy-duty trash bags, surveillance video, a Toyota Yaris that narrows the suspect pool, and an interview strategy that finally gets Hoffman talking. The ending is as haunting as the beginning, with a confession leading to bodies hidden inside a hollow tree and a sentence of life without parole. If you’re into Ohio true crime, kidnapping cases, and the real-world mechanics of solving murders, this one will stick with you. Subscribe, share this with a friend who loves true crime podcasts, and leave us a review with your biggest question from the case.

Source Material:

Mcniff, Eamon, January 6, 2011, Girl Tells Rapist who Killed her Mom She is No longer Afraid of Him, https://abcnews.com/TheLaw/hoffman-pleads-guilty-gruesome-ohio-killings-abduction/story?id=12555832

Associate Press, February 9, 2011, Ohio Killer: Bodies in Tree, Squirrels in Freezer, https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna41494970

10tv.com, January 6, 2011, Man Gets Life in Prison for Knox County Slayings, Rape, https://www.10tv.com/article/news/man-gets-life-prison-knox-county-slayings-rape/530-69a50d78-c681-49a5-8a9e-eef96249dac3