Episode Details

These sources provide detailed accounts of five cold cases that remained a mystery for decades before reaching resolution. The first case describes the 1986 kidnapping of Jessica Gutierrez, where a witness’s description of a "wizard hat" was eventually linked to a cowboy-hat-wearing suspect convicted through fingerprint analysis. Similarly, the 1972 murder of Debbie Randall and the 1987 double homicide of Tanya Van Cuylenborg and Jay Cook were solved through genetic genealogy, a modern forensic technique using public DNA databases to identify relatives of the killers. The 1988 death of Melissa Tremblay also utilized this technology to charge a former prison guard who lived near the crime scene. Finally, the 1966 stabbing of Karen Snider reached a breakthrough in 2024 when a DNA match led to the arrest of a 79-year-old former friend of the family. Together, these narratives highlight how technological advancements and the persistence of investigators can finally deliver justice for victims and their families.






This episode includes AI-generated content.