Episode Details
Back to Episodes
The Nickname That Killed the Second Date
Published 4 months, 2 weeks ago
Description
Intro
- Mitch reaches out after being ghosted by Jenna.
- Says they had great chemistry over drinks and a fun, easy conversation.
- Confused why she won't return texts or calls.
The Date
- Drinks, laughs, and lots in common.
- Mitch thought the date went extremely well.
- No arguments, awkward moments, or red flags (so he thought).
The Reveal
- Jenna says the date took a turn when Mitch insisted she call him by his nickname: "Booger."
- He repeatedly corrected her whenever she called him Mitch.
- Then he shared the childhood story behind the nickname, involving actual boogers.
Mitch's Defense
- Says everyone in his life calls him Booger.
- Believes anyone close to him should use the nickname too.
- Doesn't understand why it's a dealbreaker.
Jenna's Reaction
- Couldn't get past calling a grown man "Booger."
- Says it killed any romantic attraction.
- Refused a second date.
Final Verdict
- Mitch calls Jenna shallow.
- Jenna stands firm: no second date.
- The show debates whether a nickname alone can ruin a relationship.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.