To Be and Do Podcast

Episode Overview

In this episode, Phil Amerson reflects on new research from the Hartford Institute for Religion Research regarding recent trends in American religious life. The episode explores the nuanced realities behind church attendance numbers, the influence and limitations of megachurch culture, and the often-overlooked power of small congregational acts. Amerson recounts personal experiences from pastoral work, sharing stories that reveal how renewal happens not just through numbers, but in the everyday acts of community, faith, and grace. The episode ends with a moving meditation on the concept of grace, drawing from the writings of Frederick Buechner.

Three Key Takeaways

1. Religious Involvement is Experiencing Modest Growth—But Not a Traditional Revival

Recent research from the Hartford Institute for Religion Research indicates a shift in religious engagement after decades of decline. Where average church attendance had dropped dramatically—from 135 in 2000 to just 45 during the COVID pandemic—it is now climbing back above 65 (01:19). Though some claim these numbers mark a religious revival, Amerson emphasizes a more nuanced picture: the increase is real, but modest and often concentrated in certain areas, especially within megachurches.

2. Megachurches Aren’t the Only Places Where Renewal Happens

While researchers like Scott Tooma and high-profile pastors like Adam Hamilton focus on megachurch growth as the vector for the future of American religion, Speaker A challenges this perspective. The episode argues that small, local congregations—both urban and rural—play a crucial role in community life and spiritual vitality (04:49). These smaller communities offer meaning, belonging, and empowerment in ways that aren’t always reflected in attendance statistics.

3. Grace and Renewal Are Found in Small Acts and Relationships

Drawing on personal experiences at Broadway United Methodist Church, Amerson recounts stories of individuals whose quiet faith and generosity became the backbone of vibrant congregational life (07:20). By highlighting the unseen power centers within small gatherings—such as a handful of women meeting for healing and Bible study—the episode illustrates that genuine renewal is about joy, restoration, and the rediscovery of shared purpose, not just numerical growth. The episode’s closing passages center on the profound and unearned nature of grace (12:21), encouraging listeners to recognize and accept the abundance already present in their lives.

Listen and subscribe for thoughtful discussions on meaning, purpose, and the everyday ways we shape our shared life.