Episode Details
Back to Episodes
Secretary: What It Gets Right About BDSM | A Sub Is Born
Description
Secretary sex scene breakdown: what the film gets right (and wrong) about BDSM, plus the sexiest no-contact scene in film history.
An intimacy coordinator's take on power, kink, and consent
Maggie Gyllenhaal. James Spader. A desk. And a worm that somehow becomes the hottest moment in the movie.
Secretary changed how Hollywood talked about kink on screen. But does it hold up? Ariel and Morgan break down the iconic, controversial, and deeply weird BDSM film that people are still arguing about 20 years later.
In this episode:
• The worm scene — why anticipation and eye contact are sexier than touch
• The Peter problem: she's asking for domination. He's giving nothing.
• Why "no safe word, no conversation" is doing a LOT of heavy lifting
• Kink as emotional connection vs. kink as self-harm replacement
• Breath work that deserves awards and hand spasms that steal the show
The verdict: No notes. (Okay... some notes.)
Watch along timestamps:
- Secretary: "Peter Scene": 1:08:34
- Secretary: "Worm Scene": 1:10:54
- Secretary: "Aftercare/Gardening Scene": 1:41:47
This episode is for you if:
• You love cult classics from the early 2000s
• You want to understand why Secretary is still discussed
• You're curious about BDSM representation on film
• You're a fan of Maggie Gyllenhaal or James Spader
Subscribe for bi-weekly behind the scenes breakdowns of film and TV's most iconic sex scenes.
Credits
Secretary (2002) | Director: Steven Shainberg | Starring: Maggie Gyllenhaal, James Spader | Lionsgate
Hashtags
#SecretaryMovie #BDSMfilm #IntimacyCoordinator #CultClassic #FilmBreakdown
Research sources:
- HuffPost: Forget 50 Shades: Feminist Adult Film Producers Pick Their Favorite BDSM Erotica
- Kamera: An Interview with Maggie Gyllenhaal
- ScreenSlam: James Spader Exclusive Interview
Connect & Support the Show
Watch video versions on Spotify and YouTube.
Suggest a Scene & Get Bonus Content: Join our Patreon to request scenes and unlock exclusive bonus episodes.
Follow Us: Instagram & TikTok @FakingItThePod
Website: FakingItThePod.com
Theme Song: Faking It by Mike Goetz
Subscribe & Review
Never miss an episode — subscribe wherever you listen. Love the show? A 5-star rating helps other listeners find us.
Stay real, Fakers.
For entertainment and educational purposes only. All trademarks and copyrights remain with their respective owners.