Episode Details
Back to Episodes
3 Allegedly True Craigslist Marketplace Horror Stories _ Vol. 3
Season 1
Episode 226
Published 4 months, 3 weeks ago
Description
"You're scrolling for a used couch. A vintage lamp. Maybe a good deal on a lawnmower. You don't know that the seller's basement has a history the real estate listing never mentioned—and you're about to walk right into it."
In this spine-chilling episode of Grief—Volume 3 of our Craigslist Horror series—we present three allegedly true stories of online marketplace transactions that took a terrifying turn.
Story 1: "The Free Sofa" – A broke college student answers an ad for a free sofa in a wealthy suburb. The seller is almost too friendly. She offers coffee. She asks personal questions. When the student returns with her dad's truck the next day, the house is empty—except for a locked basement door and a faint smell she'll never forget.
Story 2: "The Vintage Mirror" – A woman buys a beautiful antique mirror from an estate sale listing. The first night, she wakes at exactly 3:17 AM to find the mirror has moved three inches closer to her bed. By the third night, the reflection no longer matches her movements.
Story 3: "The Buyer Who Stayed" – A man lists his late father's car. A buyer offers cash, full price. They meet in a public parking lot. The buyer asks to hear the engine one more time. Then he locks the doors and says: "Let's go for a drive. You're not going to call the cops—your phone's in the trunk."
Dramatized but based on real Craigslist incident reports, police blotters, and firsthand accounts submitted to horror forums. No graphic descriptions—just the slow, creeping dread of realizing you've walked into something you can't walk out of. Turn off the lights. Put on headphones. And never meet a stranger alone again. Press play—if you dare.
In this spine-chilling episode of Grief—Volume 3 of our Craigslist Horror series—we present three allegedly true stories of online marketplace transactions that took a terrifying turn.
Story 1: "The Free Sofa" – A broke college student answers an ad for a free sofa in a wealthy suburb. The seller is almost too friendly. She offers coffee. She asks personal questions. When the student returns with her dad's truck the next day, the house is empty—except for a locked basement door and a faint smell she'll never forget.
Story 2: "The Vintage Mirror" – A woman buys a beautiful antique mirror from an estate sale listing. The first night, she wakes at exactly 3:17 AM to find the mirror has moved three inches closer to her bed. By the third night, the reflection no longer matches her movements.
Story 3: "The Buyer Who Stayed" – A man lists his late father's car. A buyer offers cash, full price. They meet in a public parking lot. The buyer asks to hear the engine one more time. Then he locks the doors and says: "Let's go for a drive. You're not going to call the cops—your phone's in the trunk."
Dramatized but based on real Craigslist incident reports, police blotters, and firsthand accounts submitted to horror forums. No graphic descriptions—just the slow, creeping dread of realizing you've walked into something you can't walk out of. Turn off the lights. Put on headphones. And never meet a stranger alone again. Press play—if you dare.