Episode Details
Back to Episodes
American Idol Season 24 Episode 16 (The Finale) | String Cheese Success and Social Media Scrambles
Published 1 week, 4 days ago
Description
The confetti has officially fallen on Season 24 of American Idol, and the snark squad is unpacking a finale that proves in 2026, a viral anthem about the "un-glamorous" side of motherhood is worth more than a perfect high note. We’re deep-diving into the historic win of Hannah Harper, the 25-year-old Missouri stay-at-home mom who went from "Willow Springs wonder" to the first female country artist to ever claim the crown. After her original song "String Cheese"—a raw, vulnerable look at her journey with postpartum depression—blew up on TikTok, Hannah used that momentum to steamroll through the competition. We’re asking: did Hannah win because she was the best vocalist, or because she was the most "relatable" contestant to ever grace the Idol stage?
The drama reached a "Digital" peak with the introduction of the season's most polarizing twist: social media voting. Instead of just texting a number, fans were sifting through pinned posts and comment sections to cast their ballots, leading to a "messy" night of bot-account accusations and misspelling disqualifications. While the judges—including a returning Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—celebrated Hannah’s "emotional power," a vocal segment of the internet is calling foul. The "McCullough Mob" is out in full force, arguing that runner-up Jordan McCullough was "robbed" of the title despite his flawless vocals and "Platinum Ticket" status. We’re unpacking the three-hour star-studded event, from Carrie Underwood rocking out with Mötley Crüe to Keyla Richardson’s third-place finish after an emotional Jason Mraz duet. We’re asking: is American Idol still a singing competition, or has the new voting system officially turned it into a "popularity contest" where the best story beats the best singer?
LOVE THE DRAMA? JOIN THE SNARK SQUAD!
If you’re obsessed with reality TV recaps, roasting your favorite TLC and Bravo stars, and messy tea, make sure to subscribe! We dive into the wildest dating shows and reality drama every week.
LISTEN & SUBSCRIBE: Catch every episode of The Snark Side Podcast on your favorite streaming platform:
The drama reached a "Digital" peak with the introduction of the season's most polarizing twist: social media voting. Instead of just texting a number, fans were sifting through pinned posts and comment sections to cast their ballots, leading to a "messy" night of bot-account accusations and misspelling disqualifications. While the judges—including a returning Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—celebrated Hannah’s "emotional power," a vocal segment of the internet is calling foul. The "McCullough Mob" is out in full force, arguing that runner-up Jordan McCullough was "robbed" of the title despite his flawless vocals and "Platinum Ticket" status. We’re unpacking the three-hour star-studded event, from Carrie Underwood rocking out with Mötley Crüe to Keyla Richardson’s third-place finish after an emotional Jason Mraz duet. We’re asking: is American Idol still a singing competition, or has the new voting system officially turned it into a "popularity contest" where the best story beats the best singer?
LOVE THE DRAMA? JOIN THE SNARK SQUAD!
If you’re obsessed with reality TV recaps, roasting your favorite TLC and Bravo stars, and messy tea, make sure to subscribe! We dive into the wildest dating shows and reality drama every week.
LISTEN & SUBSCRIBE: Catch every episode of The Snark Side Podcast on your favorite streaming platform:
- Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-snark-side-the-chaotic-world-of-tlc-bravo-and-reality-tv/id1846240963
- Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3Qt1mPbJ3eH1VlEyQYTqfO